No add 8vs8

Started 13 Jan 2020
by mcvinc
in Ask the Team
Hello sorry my english.

When you engage fight mid alb. Alb and mid desengage.

And they fight us and after us death they back.

It's normal?
Mon 13 Jan 2020 10:44 PM by Azrael
Yes, usually all 8man are doing this. If you add their fight they switch and fight the adding 3rd party.
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:09 PM by Amser
Azrael wrote: Yes, usually all 8man are doing this. If you add their fight they switch and fight the adding 3rd party.

What he said. All 3 realm's 8 mans do it.

8v8's have decided they are kings/queens of the frontier and have created their own rules of war. They have no issues adding (or running down) smallmen or solo's but heaven forbid you add their 8v8 "fairfights". I don't particularly have any issues with them doing this when it is done in more remote locations, but when you fight at the most clustered areas of beno/bled/crau (or task keeps) you should expect to be added. 100% of the time it has happened to me it was at those named locations.
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:17 PM by Pao
Hate to hear dumb stuff like this especially when I get killed solo all the time nobody honour my soloness....
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:21 PM by gotwqqd
Amser wrote:
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:09 PM
Azrael wrote: Yes, usually all 8man are doing this. If you add their fight they switch and fight the adding 3rd party.

What he said. All 3 realm's 8 mans do it.

8v8's have decided they are kings/queens of the frontier and have created their own rules of war. They have no issues adding (or running down) smallmen or solo's but heaven forbid you add their 8v8 "fairfights". I don't particularly have any issues with them doing this when it is done in more remote locations, but when you fight at the most clustered areas of beno/bled/crau (or task keeps) you should expect to be added. 100% of the time it has happened to me it was at those named locations.
I don’t care where it’s done, when you disengage the enemy and let them kill your realmmates it is against the spirit of the game
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:28 PM by Amser
gotwqqd wrote:
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:21 PM
Amser wrote:
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:09 PM
Azrael wrote: Yes, usually all 8man are doing this. If you add their fight they switch and fight the adding 3rd party.

What he said. All 3 realm's 8 mans do it.

8v8's have decided they are kings/queens of the frontier and have created their own rules of war. They have no issues adding (or running down) smallmen or solo's but heaven forbid you add their 8v8 "fairfights". I don't particularly have any issues with them doing this when it is done in more remote locations, but when you fight at the most clustered areas of beno/bled/crau (or task keeps) you should expect to be added. 100% of the time it has happened to me it was at those named locations.
I don’t care where it’s done, when you disengage the enemy and let them kill your realmmates it is against the spirit of the game

"it is against the spirit of the game"
I agree with that statement.

I also think about it from their point of view. They are just trying to play the game their way as 8v8 without adds "fairfight". The GM's basically lined this up for them with the in game command. If they are off in a remote location, it is likely to occur much less and people would know not to go back there. Can't really just avoid border keeps/docks/tasks though.
Tue 14 Jan 2020 12:01 AM by Turano
the 8 man elitists have always been hypocritical snowflakes
adding or hunting down solos and small man grps is absolutely fine but god forbid someone disturbs their holy 8v8 engagements
Tue 14 Jan 2020 1:52 AM by Forlornhope
The 8man elitest crap is what drives most other players to zerg, which creates less action for the 8mans other than ganking bridges and docks outside of main keeps. Which makes smallmans/solos quit. It's funny, you can already see it happening... maybe 10 set 8mans running around (maybe 2 or three max during NA prime) zero small mans or solos, with one mid zerg. The server action sucks and has driven most people to either zerg or quit.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:08 AM by atomico
They are the ruin of this game.

They want fair-fight, but no problem to kill you if you are solo/smallmen.
They stay in active frontier and stop combat if you add them.

GO IN A DAMN ISOLATED FRONTIER if you want fair play, or go in EV.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 11:11 AM by gotwqqd
atomico wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:08 AM
They are the ruin of this game.

They want fair-fight, but no problem to kill you if you are solo/smallmen.
They stay in active frontier and stop combat if you add them.

GO IN A DAMN ISOLATED FRONTIER if you want fair play, or go in EV.
I think they need a new game
They are toxic to their own realm
Sat 18 Jan 2020 3:40 PM by DaleRod
This is the best game ever. It is a RVR game. Realm vs Realm not 8 v 8 game where you stop the fight and watch your 3 realm mates get rolled by the other realm. I stopped playing this game on another server years ago because of the 8 v 8 nonsense. Stop enabling the 8 v 8 toxin with the fair fight. Give them a zone they can go play in and let the rest of us enjoy this great RVR game.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM by inoeth
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:28 PM by Forlornhope
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself

That's really not the case, except in very few instances. 8mans add anything that's not another 8man, and they'll even add those if they feel like it. It doesn't matter if you've added in the past or not.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:30 PM by inoeth
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:28 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself

That's really not the case, except in very few instances. 8mans add anything that's not another 8man, and they'll even add those if they feel like it. It doesn't matter if you've added in the past or not.

serious 8 mans do not add
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:36 PM by Forlornhope
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:30 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:28 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself

That's really not the case, except in very few instances. 8mans add anything that's not another 8man, and they'll even add those if they feel like it. It doesn't matter if you've added in the past or not.

serious 8 mans do not add

If it's not an 8v8, yeah they do. Which is the problem with their way of thinking, you can add anything you want indiscriminately unless it's one of the other established 8mans and expect people to not add on you. I have been added on by just about everyone of the 8mans who are still around. So either there aren't any "serious" 8mans left or they're all full of shit.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:58 PM by inoeth
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:36 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:30 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:28 PM
That's really not the case, except in very few instances. 8mans add anything that's not another 8man, and they'll even add those if they feel like it. It doesn't matter if you've added in the past or not.

serious 8 mans do not add

If it's not an 8v8, yeah they do. Which is the problem with their way of thinking, you can add anything you want indiscriminately unless it's one of the other established 8mans and expect people to not add on you. I have been added on by just about everyone of the 8mans who are still around. So either there aren't any "serious" 8mans left or they're all full of shit.

very few left, all others left because of the stupid zerg
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:58 PM by Azuell
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself

Yeah that's just false. 8 mans have been rolling solos and small mans since server launch. I can count the number of times an 8 man has let me go as a duo/trio on one hand and we never add 8v8s.

What's your name in game and guild/colors so I can call you out on it when you guys inevitably roll us?
Sat 18 Jan 2020 7:41 PM by Pao
I have brand new solo chars never added any 8vs8 and get killed every single time by an 8man. Stop this dumb narrative of honoured 8man and dumb zerg. Never seen a 8 man not adding a 1vs1 or leave a solo alone... life with the zerg as we have to life with you 8man *peeeeep* Edited. Greetings, Uthred.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 8:05 PM by chryso
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
l2p
zerg is killing the game
8 mans killing solos and smallies because solos and smallies constantly adding fights
just dont add and you get rewarded by not getting added yourself

You go first.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:06 PM by chryso
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:58 PM
very few left, all others left because of the stupid zerg

There is no zerg on uthgard. You should check it out.
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:40 PM by Quik
chryso wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:06 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:58 PM
very few left, all others left because of the stupid zerg

There is no zerg on uthgard. You should check it out.

Just a question, but isn't a zerg more of a true RvR style of gameplay then 8v8 is?

1v1, 2v2, 4v4, 8v8 - basically fortnite/pubg with teams.

Zerg technically is DAoC since it is SUPPOSE to be RvRvR which means 3 realms against each other. Not you vs a specific other person and people getting upset about adds. Realm vs realm implies 1 army against another army and an army is basically a zerg of people.

Why do people feel like 1 group against another group is how DAoC was meant to be played? If that was the case there would be set arenas like ESO and not an open world fighting system meant for hundreds/thousands to fight each other.
Sun 19 Jan 2020 12:00 AM by Forlornhope
Quik wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:40 PM
chryso wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 10:06 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:58 PM
very few left, all others left because of the stupid zerg

There is no zerg on uthgard. You should check it out.

Just a question, but isn't a zerg more of a true RvR style of gameplay then 8v8 is?

1v1, 2v2, 4v4, 8v8 - basically fortnite/pubg with teams.

Zerg technically is DAoC since it is SUPPOSE to be RvRvR which means 3 realms against each other. Not you vs a specific other person and people getting upset about adds. Realm vs realm implies 1 army against another army and an army is basically a zerg of people.

Why do people feel like 1 group against another group is how DAoC was meant to be played? If that was the case there would be set arenas like ESO and not an open world fighting system meant for hundreds/thousands to fight each other.

You are correct, but careful the high an mighty 8mans will just belittle you and how you want to play if you don't live up to their standards/hypocritical rule set.
Sun 19 Jan 2020 8:41 AM by inoeth
that is not how it is at all. there is no "true" or "false" type of gameplay in daoc.
solo, small, 8, zerg ... its all possible
whats lacks is the respect for the other play styles and by that i mean zergers dont respect anyone!
i mean on the one hand you guys complain about "elitist 8 man" hunting down your solo or smallie, on the other hand you add every fight in sight.
why dont you just go to the zerg zone and do your one button game play? no thats not enough, you need to ruin others ppl fun in this game.

also i can understand that the guys who really want to play fair give up at some point when they constantly get added.... mainly by the bigger zergs.
at some point you might say fuck it i add these mofos.

still there are 8 mans who are really respectfull and who will kick you out of the grp if you start to add.

everyone should just calm down, think about other players ( es behind every toon there is a human looking for some fun in game) and decide if it is really worth zerging down solos with 5+ for 10rp? or let this guy have his kill, zerg him down afterwards and then he might come back?! the thing is if you constantly get raped, you get to the point where playing the game is no fun anymore and what i do, i simply log off. is it that what you want, making ppl want to log off? grats you got it.
Mon 20 Jan 2020 12:04 PM by Lux.Thoras
This discussion is as old as the game itself.
In the end, there only one truth: everybody should and can play as she/he preffers

There will be never a way to get all people playing the game in the same way or to bring all to the same opinion and this is good.
From my point of view, everybody can play as he wants’. Solo, Small men, 8 men, zerg, adding or not. Doesn´t matter.

The biggest problem i see is, that the respect is missing, the respect for the playstyle of the others.
So, if you get added, take your consequences, but don´t blame the others for their way of playing.
If you get zerged, take your consequences, but don´t blame the others for their way of playing.
If you get jumped by bigger number or 8mans jump into zerg fight, take your consequences, but don´t blame the others for their way of playing.

I am mostly playing 8men or solo. If i run solo, i have to live with getting jumped by small men, 8 men or zergs, there it makes no difference, everybody is running behind a solo. But this is my problem, because i have chosen the option to run solo, so i have to take the consequence with getting killed by larger numbers.

If i play in 8 men, we sometimes have add. Then we have to live with it, we can´t change it.
The most important point for me is: Playing with my friends and having fun during that time.
Mon 20 Jan 2020 2:15 PM by Sepplord
Lux.Thoras wrote:
Mon 20 Jan 2020 12:04 PM
[...]

I agree i general, but i disagree on the complete freedom of playing how you want. There is a reason why griefplaying-rules exist. Because simply letting people do what they want always leads to some people "wanting to destroy the fun of others".

Imo, an 8man pulling off of a fight to let their realmmates die is borderline griefplaying WHEN it happens in LOS to a taskkeep for example. I just can't find any explanation why an 8man that wants to play by "those rules" would even BE near a taskkeep, let alone start a fight with another 8man there instead of running somewhere else (or just BEING Somewhere else in the first place). The only explanation is that they actually want these situations to happen and/or are even coordinating it.

When someone adds an 8vs8 in EV or another remote place, then they deserve getting killed while both previously fighting 8man do celebrating dance emotes on their corpsed before resetting/restarting their fight or going their own ways again.



It's not only 8mans though ofcourse. I have heard plenty of solos/smallmenpeople say stuff along the lines of: i will keep adding every 8vs8 they see. I don't care if they pull off and kil me, their fight is ruined anyways.


Both "offenses" are almost impossible to police though, so i understand why there's no official stance on it
Mon 20 Jan 2020 2:26 PM by gotwqqd
Sepplord wrote:
Mon 20 Jan 2020 2:15 PM
Lux.Thoras wrote:
Mon 20 Jan 2020 12:04 PM
[...]

I agree i general, but i disagree on the complete freedom of playing how you want. There is a reason why griefplaying-rules exist. Because simply letting people do what they want always leads to some people "wanting to destroy the fun of others".

Imo, an 8man pulling off of a fight to let their realmmates die is borderline griefplaying WHEN it happens in LOS to a taskkeep for example. I just can't find any explanation why an 8man that wants to play by "those rules" would even BE near a taskkeep, let alone start a fight with another 8man there instead of running somewhere else (or just BEING Somewhere else in the first place). The only explanation is that they actually want these situations to happen and/or are even coordinating it.

When someone adds an 8vs8 in EV or another remote place, then they deserve getting killed while both previously fighting 8man do celebrating dance emotes on their corpsed before resetting/restarting their fight or going their own ways again.



It's not only 8mans though ofcourse. I have heard plenty of solos/smallmenpeople say stuff along the lines of: i will keep adding every 8vs8 they see. I don't care if they pull off and kil me, their fight is ruined anyways.


Both "offenses" are almost impossible to police though, so i understand why there's no official stance on it
Sorry but I go further

It’s not okay under Any circumstances to allow a realm mates to die because they help with combat against an enemy.

The ones that wish for “set” conflicts need to keep trying and be happy when they get them.
Mon 20 Jan 2020 3:48 PM by Azrael
Sepplord wrote:
Mon 20 Jan 2020 2:15 PM
Imo, an 8man pulling off of a fight to let their realmmates die is borderline griefplaying WHEN it happens in LOS to a taskkeep for example. I just can't find any explanation why an 8man that wants to play by "those rules" would even BE near a taskkeep, let alone start a fight with another 8man there instead of running somewhere else (or just BEING Somewhere else in the first place). The only explanation is that they actually want these situations to happen and/or are even coordinating it.


As far is I can tell it is not coordinated in any way. They are in the zerg zones so they get these additional jucy rps for farming worse/smaller groups. It would be pretty easy to go other zones but they would miss a lot of rps, so they prefer to get these rps and also prefer to complain about adds or getting zerged by the zerg sometimes.
I also experienced situation where I get cursed after adding an 8man fight in LOS of a keep and dock. At the same time they state you can't complain about getting added near a dock or a keep, so that leads me to the conclusion they are stupid in some way. (double standards)

Just for the notes, I also do 8man and smallman and I appreciate fair fight and I also complain about adds (but only in ts/discord) I don't send them to fuck off.
Mon 20 Jan 2020 6:22 PM by Inactas
I just rerolled to alb after being gone for several months. Has this server basically turned into a few 8v8s and basically their underlings following the guidelines they set? Not that anyone cares about a single player coming or going, but I certainly don't want to play here if it's simply a controlled 8v8 fest, every server in the past has dwindled in population and went this route...and it never picks back up, it slowly decays the server in exchange for a handful of people's preferred DAoC style. Please tell me this is not the case so I don't continue to waste time here. I like 8v8 but I also enjoy every aspect of DAoC(Excluding 3 hours PvE raids.)
Mon 20 Jan 2020 6:34 PM by Forlornhope
Inactas wrote:
Mon 20 Jan 2020 6:22 PM
I just rerolled to alb after being gone for several months. Has this server basically turned into a few 8v8s and basically their underlings following the guidelines they set? Not that anyone cares about a single player coming or going, but I certainly don't want to play here if it's simply a controlled 8v8 fest, every server in the past has dwindled in population and went this route...and it never picks back up, it slowly decays the server in exchange for a handful of people's preferred DAoC style. Please tell me this is not the case so I don't continue to waste time here. I like 8v8 but I also enjoy every aspect of DAoC(Excluding 3 hours PvE raids.)

Depending on the timezone you play it will differ. There is almost always a mid/hib zerg on during EU, and there is always a mid zerg on during NA time. There may be more set 8mans during EU time, I am not too familiar with since I play NA time.. but most of these 8mans have devolved into adding any other fight that's not in their little established 8v8 community then getting butt hurt if anyone responds in kind and adds theirs. Which normally leads to them breaking off a fight letting their realm mates die and then resetting their own fight with the other group. They will also role over solos/small mans and camp docks all day.
Mon 20 Jan 2020 11:16 PM by Cadebrennus
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:36 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:30 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Sat 18 Jan 2020 6:28 PM
That's really not the case, except in very few instances. 8mans add anything that's not another 8man, and they'll even add those if they feel like it. It doesn't matter if you've added in the past or not.

serious 8 mans do not add

If it's not an 8v8, yeah they do. Which is the problem with their way of thinking, you can add anything you want indiscriminately unless it's one of the other established 8mans and expect people to not add on you. I have been added on by just about everyone of the 8mans who are still around. So either there aren't any "serious" 8mans left or they're all full of shit.

They're all *peeep*. Language, edited by Uthred. It was this way on Live too.
Tue 21 Jan 2020 8:09 AM by Razur Ur
If i running solo in frontier zone, get i most time raped from 8vs8 groups :-/. i guess my celt champion is to sexy for some groups :-D
Tue 21 Jan 2020 8:41 AM by Lux.Thoras
Razur Ur wrote:
Tue 21 Jan 2020 8:09 AM
If i running solo in frontier zone, get i most time raped from 8vs8 groups :-/. i guess my celt champion is to sexy for some groups :-D

I would say, you are to dangerous to stay alive



To topic, the biggest Issue i see is, complaining about not being allowed to play the way you want, but not letting others play the way they want is a bit schizophrenic.
In most cases, people feel treated unfairly if they get killed somehow they did not expect. To clear this frustration, most people start complaining about that in the forum or elsewhere. If they are not frustrated, they will not comlain about. This is why most of the Topics are about complaining about something or someone.

Generalizing everything is not the right way. For every type of playstyle (Solo, small men, 8men, zerg) you will find friendly people, accepting others and their playstle and people which are looking only on their self. From my experience, the friendly people are much more. But the others cry louder, so this is the case why you hear them more.

For those people, is always like: On the other hand, the grass is always greener.

What i mean: If 8men fight on Bridges, Boatspot, Towers or Keeps there is a 100% chance to be added by someone. If you ignore this and complain about, then it is not the fault of others, it is the 8men fault. Or running the hole evening in the same zone 8 men where also the zerg is running and then complain about the zerg adding your fights, is stupid. For 8 men you can also run within another zone.

So it would be better if everyone look outside the box.
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM by oldmanukko
lol, lol, lol...

"want respect? show respect!" (you can take that lesson out of daoc and apply it to real life, fyi)

this is a red-is-dead server. end of story. no discussion.

if your 8-man wants some respect, stop rolling small-man and solos.
your small-man wants respect for smallman-vs-smallman, stop rolling solo's.

until smallman can run around finding only small-vs-small fights, we will add your precious 8v8...
until i can run around solo finding 1v1 fights, i will always add on your precious 8v8 and small-vs-small.

we ALL take rps where we can find them.

it's really quite simple.

the ignorance of these posts blows me away.

if you still don't understand the complete and total hypocrisy here, let me put it this way..
"Group Leader: hey look, a solo running around.. this game is NOT for soloers. duh! they seriously need to find a group. kill them!!"
...moments later
"Group Leader: we are getting a clean 8v8, this is so fun!!!"
<8v8 turns to 9v8>
"Group Leader: omfg, what the F??!?!? it was all great until that solo added. why can't i get a clean 8v8 tonight?!?!?!"



“Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”
― Mahatma Gandhi
Sat 25 Jan 2020 5:35 PM by Forlornhope
oldmanukko wrote:
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM

Agree with everything you said, it's hilarious when people complain about getting added when they roll solos with 8mans all day.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 8:46 AM by inoeth
oldmanukko wrote:
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM
lol, lol, lol...

"want respect? show respect!" (you can take that lesson out of daoc and apply it to real life, fyi)

this is a red-is-dead server. end of story. no discussion.

if your 8-man wants some respect, stop rolling small-man and solos.
your small-man wants respect for smallman-vs-smallman, stop rolling solo's.

until smallman can run around finding only small-vs-small fights, we will add your precious 8v8...
until i can run around solo finding 1v1 fights, i will always add on your precious 8v8 and small-vs-small.

we ALL take rps where we can find them.

it's really quite simple.

the ignorance of these posts blows me away.

if you still don't understand the complete and total hypocrisy here, let me put it this way..
"Group Leader: hey look, a solo running around.. this game is NOT for soloers. duh! they seriously need to find a group. kill them!!"
...moments later
"Group Leader: we are getting a clean 8v8, this is so fun!!!"
<8v8 turns to 9v8>
"Group Leader: omfg, what the F??!?!? it was all great until that solo added. why can't i get a clean 8v8 tonight?!?!?!"



“Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”
― Mahatma Gandhi

show me where anyone of the devs said this is a red is dead server!
fake news!
Sun 26 Jan 2020 12:11 PM by Chaskha
inoeth wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 8:46 AM
oldmanukko wrote:
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM
... if you still don't understand the complete and total hypocrisy here, let me put it this way..
"Group Leader: hey look, a solo running around.. this game is NOT for soloers. duh! they seriously need to find a group. kill them!!"
...moments later
"Group Leader: we are getting a clean 8v8, this is so fun!!!"
<8v8 turns to 9v8>
"Group Leader: omfg, what the F??!?!? it was all great until that solo added. why can't i get a clean 8v8 tonight?!?!?!"


“Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”
― Mahatma Gandhi

show me where anyone of the devs said this is a red is dead server!
fake news!
This is a red is dead GAME.
8v8 people may have invented rules to make the game more fun - in their opinion (and there's no argument they get the most thrilling experience of DAoC) - it doesn't change the fact that the game is 3 realms at war and no fairness at all once you put foot in frontiers... that's the whole reason why people leveling in frontiers would have better XP but would have to deal with being grey ganked.... it's not blue team versus green team versus red team with salute and oh please sir, I see the peasant there want in, let us all nobles watch him get killed, he is, after all just a peasant uh uh uh ... No, it's a fucking blood bath and invaders should be pushed away !

I have the most fun in smallmen and yes, I get you have more fun with 8v8 but the essence of the game is red is dead.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 1:24 PM by opossum12
Not sure why there is a debate on red is dead and what the server is.

The game is realm vs realm, and first of all, it is a game.

If two groups are having a fun doing 8v8 and a solo adds, it is normal behavior for one group to pull off and let the other group kill the add.

It is also completely normal for that solo to try to turn the favor of the fight to one aide or the other by adding.

It's all part of the game.

Red is dead is one philosophy, 8v8 is another, solo is another, and so on.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 3:57 PM by bigne88
8 men comunity is a really small percent of the server, don't forget this.

I, we, wathever, dont complain if we get added, we just disengage and clear the adders.

The few party that are on the /gvg toggle list never add a 1v1, 2v2 or wathever; of course if a soloer or a small men is on their way, they will kill it, but for sure they wont chase.

Though there are some 8 men party that wont join the /gvg toggle list and will hunt and add anything that moves...thous people are just playing the game with their friends without following any rule. Thous players are as casual as keeptakers/zergers but prefer to play in a more organized way without being hardcore 8 men.

The most important point tougn is that zergers/keeptakers nobs/casuals have massive RP bonuses and gains...8 men dosent have anything like that, thats why low-mid rank 8men party will kill anything on sight that gives RPs.
If 8v8 would give the same amount of Rps as keeptake is giving atm, trust me, noone of this 8men will be seeing again around docks.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 4:14 PM by inoeth
bigne88 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 3:57 PM
8 men comunity is a really small percent of the server, don't forget this.

I, we, wathever, dont complain if we get added, we just disengage and clear the adders.

The few party that are on the /gvg toggle list never add a 1v1, 2v2 or wathever; of course if a soloer or a small men is on their way, they will kill it, but for sure they wont chase.

Though there are some 8 men party that wont join the /gvg toggle list and will hunt and add anything that moves...thous people are just playing the game with their friends without following any rule. Thous players are as casual as keeptakers/zergers but prefer to play in a more organized way without being hardcore 8 men.

The most important point tougn is that zergers/keeptakers nobs/casuals have massive RP bonuses and gains...8 men dosent have anything like that, thats why low-mid rank 8men party will kill anything on sight that gives RPs.
If 8v8 would give the same amount of Rps as keeptake is giving atm, trust me, noone of this 8men will be seeing again around docks.

the highest rrs here are 8v8 players....
rps are not a problem at all
its just that some ppl like challenge and some like to not use their brain, very simple
Sun 26 Jan 2020 4:15 PM by watbrif
opossum12 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 1:24 PM
Red is dead is one philosophy, 8v8 is another, solo is another, and so on.

I think we all know that these "philosophies" don't coexist, because "Red is dead" is incompatible with 8vs8 etc. But, as has been pointed out, the way the game mechanics are the designed (i.e. no penalties for adding, no penalties for killing greys) mean "red is dead" is the default mode - and most people play this way (because most people want to have fun, get some rps and don't want to turn this game into some e-sports competition). I'm all for respecting people's different ways, but there's no right to enforce a certain "philosophy" EXCEPT "red is dead" (you can't walk out on your realm mates if they disturb your 8vs8).
Sun 26 Jan 2020 5:29 PM by opossum12
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 4:15 PM
opossum12 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 1:24 PM
Red is dead is one philosophy, 8v8 is another, solo is another, and so on.

I think we all know that these "philosophies" don't coexist, because "Red is dead" is incompatible with 8vs8 etc. But, as has been pointed out, the way the game mechanics are the designed (i.e. no penalties for adding, no penalties for killing greys) mean "red is dead" is the default mode - and most people play this way (because most people want to have fun, get some rps and don't want to turn this game into some e-sports competition). I'm all for respecting people's different ways, but there's no right to enforce a certain "philosophy" EXCEPT "red is dead" (you can't walk out on your realm mates if they disturb your 8vs8).

What is the /fairfight command then? You get bonus RPs when you get a clean 8v8 that didn't get jammed. That was implemented by the devs, so I'd say the devs are smart enough to identify that multiple play styles can co-exist.

I don't understand why nothing except red is dead should co-exist. I have fun playing the game in a specific way, and you do too. If you decide to add on fights and that people don't like it and let their oponents turn on you, then you have the choice to

-bring more people
-take note of the names and don't do it again

You can keep doing red is dead, that's fine. But you can't force your style on others, because apparently the devs also thought that people that like clean even fights could play on phoenix too.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:19 PM by watbrif
opossum12 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 5:29 PM
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 4:15 PM
opossum12 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 1:24 PM
Red is dead is one philosophy, 8v8 is another, solo is another, and so on.

I think we all know that these "philosophies" don't coexist, because "Red is dead" is incompatible with 8vs8 etc. But, as has been pointed out, the way the game mechanics are the designed (i.e. no penalties for adding, no penalties for killing greys) mean "red is dead" is the default mode - and most people play this way (because most people want to have fun, get some rps and don't want to turn this game into some e-sports competition). I'm all for respecting people's different ways, but there's no right to enforce a certain "philosophy" EXCEPT "red is dead" (you can't walk out on your realm mates if they disturb your 8vs8).

What is the /fairfight command then? You get bonus RPs when you get a clean 8v8 that didn't get jammed. That was implemented by the devs, so I'd say the devs are smart enough to identify that multiple play styles can co-exist.

I don't understand why nothing except red is dead should co-exist. I have fun playing the game in a specific way, and you do too. If you decide to add on fights and that people don't like it and let their oponents turn on you, then you have the choice to

-bring more people
-take note of the names and don't do it again

You can keep doing red is dead, that's fine. But you can't force your style on others, because apparently the devs also thought that people that like clean even fights could play on phoenix too.

Well, "our" devs are not the ones who originally designed the game, so introducing the gvg command etc. was basically like putting a plaster on a head wound. The only thing that would put 8vs8 on an equal footing would be handing out penalties for adding. Only THEN would 8vs8 be equal to "red is dead". Until that happens you can't blame other people for playing the game in the way they want to (i.e. killing anyone who is not from their realm). The same counts for killing greys (which is equally frustrating). Again, I get your point and I also try to to leave 1 on 1 fights and other group encounters alone (and always spare greys...). But, right now and since the beginning of DAoC time, adding has been encouraged through the game mechanics (rp rewards) and killing greys has been tolerated (because it's not penalised). And that's still the status quo...
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:58 PM by Lux.Thoras
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
Well, "our" devs are not the ones who originally designed the game, so introducing the gvg command etc. was basically like putting a plaster on a head wound. The only thing that would put 8vs8 on an equal footing would be handing out penalties for adding. Only THEN would 8vs8 be equal to "red is dead". Until that happens you can't blame other people for playing the game in the way they want to (i.e. killing anyone who is not from their realm). The same counts for killing greys (which is equally frustrating). Again, I get your point and I also try to to leave 1 on 1 fights and other group encounters alone (and always spare greys...). But, right now and since the beginning of DAoC time, adding has been encouraged through the game mechanics (rp rewards) and killing greys has been tolerated (because it's not penalised). And that's still the status quo...

Question to your argumentation, what is the group size in the game ?
64 ?
128?
256?
From your point of argumentation i can say, as long as this is not the case, the game is not designed for more than 8 persons.
Also don´t come with an BattleGroup, because a Battlegroup does not bring any benefit in RvR.

How someone think about the game, is his decision. It is not the decision of others how he has to see it.
When you buy a Porsche, you don't always have to drive 300 km / h, do you? Just because Porsche designed the car for up to 300.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 8:03 PM by watbrif
Lux.Thoras wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:58 PM
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
Well, "our" devs are not the ones who originally designed the game, so introducing the gvg command etc. was basically like putting a plaster on a head wound. The only thing that would put 8vs8 on an equal footing would be handing out penalties for adding. Only THEN would 8vs8 be equal to "red is dead". Until that happens you can't blame other people for playing the game in the way they want to (i.e. killing anyone who is not from their realm). The same counts for killing greys (which is equally frustrating). Again, I get your point and I also try to to leave 1 on 1 fights and other group encounters alone (and always spare greys...). But, right now and since the beginning of DAoC time, adding has been encouraged through the game mechanics (rp rewards) and killing greys has been tolerated (because it's not penalised). And that's still the status quo...

Question to your argumentation, what is the group size in the game ?
64 ?
128?
256?
From your point of argumentation i can say, as long as this is not the case, the game is not designed for more than 8 persons.
Also don´t come with an BattleGroup, because a Battlegroup does not bring any benefit in RvR.

How someone think about the game, is his decision. It is not the decision of others how he has to see it.
When you buy a Porsche, you don't always have to drive 300 km / h, do you? Just because Porsche designed the car for up to 300.

If RvR was designed for 8-men groups, why are we fighting for keeps .... The 8-men group size is pretty much an industry standard for PvE, in RvR on the other hand - and the clue is in the name - the Realm IS your group (so to say). Again, if Mythic had thought otherwise, they would have actively discouraged RvR-think and zerging (aka what makes RvR battles "epic" and getting RPs easy). 8vs8 is still possible of course, but all I'm saying is that 95% of the population play differently (because of the way the game mechanics work etc.) and this is something that the 8vs8 niche has to come to terms with (the way I've arranged myself with getting mowed down when running to the dockmaster for handing in rewards...) . If you really insist on group fights you must play a game where BG zerging is not possible/encouraged.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 8:56 PM by bigne88
The funny thing is that you all are talking about the behaviour of a minimum fraction of the population.
Sun 26 Jan 2020 10:19 PM by opossum12
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 6:19 PM
opossum12 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 5:29 PM
watbrif wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 4:15 PM
I think we all know that these "philosophies" don't coexist, because "Red is dead" is incompatible with 8vs8 etc. But, as has been pointed out, the way the game mechanics are the designed (i.e. no penalties for adding, no penalties for killing greys) mean "red is dead" is the default mode - and most people play this way (because most people want to have fun, get some rps and don't want to turn this game into some e-sports competition). I'm all for respecting people's different ways, but there's no right to enforce a certain "philosophy" EXCEPT "red is dead" (you can't walk out on your realm mates if they disturb your 8vs8).

What is the /fairfight command then? You get bonus RPs when you get a clean 8v8 that didn't get jammed. That was implemented by the devs, so I'd say the devs are smart enough to identify that multiple play styles can co-exist.

I don't understand why nothing except red is dead should co-exist. I have fun playing the game in a specific way, and you do too. If you decide to add on fights and that people don't like it and let their oponents turn on you, then you have the choice to

-bring more people
-take note of the names and don't do it again

You can keep doing red is dead, that's fine. But you can't force your style on others, because apparently the devs also thought that people that like clean even fights could play on phoenix too.

Well, "our" devs are not the ones who originally designed the game, so introducing the gvg command etc. was basically like putting a plaster on a head wound. The only thing that would put 8vs8 on an equal footing would be handing out penalties for adding. Only THEN would 8vs8 be equal to "red is dead". Until that happens you can't blame other people for playing the game in the way they want to (i.e. killing anyone who is not from their realm). The same counts for killing greys (which is equally frustrating). Again, I get your point and I also try to to leave 1 on 1 fights and other group encounters alone (and always spare greys...). But, right now and since the beginning of DAoC time, adding has been encouraged through the game mechanics (rp rewards) and killing greys has been tolerated (because it's not penalised). And that's still the status quo...

Oh I agree with you, I don't mind the adds tbh. What I mind is people making a big fuss about groups pulling off a fight when it happens.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 9:01 AM by Lux.Thoras
watbrif wrote: If RvR was designed for 8-men groups, why are we fighting for keeps .... The 8-men group size is pretty much an industry standard for PvE, in RvR on the other hand - and the clue is in the name - the Realm IS your group (so to say). Again, if Mythic had thought otherwise, they would have actively discouraged RvR-think and zerging (aka what makes RvR battles "epic" and getting RPs easy). 8vs8 is still possible of course, but all I'm saying is that 95% of the population play differently (because of the way the game mechanics work etc.) and this is something that the 8vs8 niche has to come to terms with (the way I've arranged myself with getting mowed down when running to the dockmaster for handing in rewards...) . If you really insist on group fights you must play a game where BG zerging is not possible/encouraged.

I think you did not get the point of my argumentation. It does not matter what the purpose of someone was when she/he designed the game. It is always on each player how he want´s to play the game. I can also take your arguments against you, if the game was not designed to play 8 men, then why does it not prevent players to run with only 8 men into the frontier zones. Also Solo´s and Smallmen should not be allowed to run outside the Borderkeep, because the game is only designed for Realm vs. Realm. Questions is, where does a Realm start ?

For me, the Realm starts with 1 Person, because he is part of the Realm and how he wants to represent HIS Realm in the Realm vs. Realm Battle, it is HIS decision and not the one of anybody else. Same is valid for Smallmen, 8Men, Zergs and anything else. Also accept the others' decision and don't complain about their playing style. This should be valid for all.



bigne88 wrote:
Sun 26 Jan 2020 8:56 PM
The funny thing is that you all are talking about the behaviour of a minimum fraction of the population.

You are absolutely right, this minority is also discriminated against.
The argumentation is sometimes so crazy.
On the one hand, 8men are destroying the the Server and the Game. (This would mean, that they are many because they would have the power to do it)
On the other hand, they are the minimum fraction of the server population. (How can they be the minimum fraction and on the other hand have the power to destroy the gameplay?)

So for me it looks like, as always, to blame someone, always the matching argument is taken.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 9:28 AM by Wolfir666
Lux.Thoras wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 9:01 AM
For me, the Realm starts with 1 Person, because he is part of the Realm and how he wants to represent HIS Realm in the Realm vs. Realm Battle, it is HIS decision and not the one of anybody else. Same is valid for Smallmen, 8Men, Zergs and anything else. Also accept the others' decision and don't complain about their playing style. This should be valid for all.


Well...
I personally think, that the word "realm" also implies some kind of "greater together" so to say.
Like, the saying "Realm vs Realm" basically also means, that 3 massive different "families" or "groups" or "armies" are battling each other.
If one person of that "Realm" basically decides, to not play for that "Realm", but rather for "the own reputation" or "the own rules", then that is of course okay in a game, but it kinda counteracts with the thought of the word "Realm".

Or to put it in other words:

It is natural, that you have to distrust the enemy.
It is natural, that you have to not believe and not rely on the enemy.
It's the enemy after all.

But if you have to distrust a "Realm-Mate", then that is no fun.
If you can't rely on someone of the same "Realm" to help you, while you help others, that is no fun.
If you are loyal to your "Realm-Mates", while these leave you alone and watch you die, that is no fun.

Yes, of course it's a game, and each to their own.
But that is, what breaks the idea of "Realm vs Realm" imho.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:07 AM by Lux.Thoras
I fully agree if we look at the definition of Realm vs Realm only.
From another point of view, i would say, Realm vs. Realm includes the Player vs Player aspect as well and there i would see all the Solos, Small men and 8men located somehow. For Player vs. Player you "can" have additional or different rules than looking only to RvR.

The importance everybody gives to the PvP aspect in that game is different and this is fine i think.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM by bigne88
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 2:30 PM by inoeth
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

100%
Mon 27 Jan 2020 4:53 PM by Forlornhope
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

You basically just described people who have known each other for years, playing different realms, who pull off a fight with each other to let their realm mates die. And you really can't see how that would frustrate other people who are not part of their accepted group of other players they've been doing this crap with for years?
Mon 27 Jan 2020 5:40 PM by opossum12
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 4:53 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

You basically just described people who have known each other for years, playing different realms, who pull off a fight with each other to let their realm mates die. And you really can't see how that would frustrate other people who are not part of their accepted group of other players they've been doing this crap with for years?

I think everybody understands that it is frustrating for the person that added the fight to be left to die. But that person learned a lesson and can:

- come back with more people
- learn the names and expect this to happen.

I think it is as frustrating for people that add to see their realm mates stop fighting and let them die as it is for the realm mates to have a fun fight ruined by an adding realm mate.

Red is dead is not universal, it is one way to play the game. You just have to understand that not everybody likes to play that way.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 6:29 PM by Forlornhope
opossum12 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 5:40 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 4:53 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

You basically just described people who have known each other for years, playing different realms, who pull off a fight with each other to let their realm mates die. And you really can't see how that would frustrate other people who are not part of their accepted group of other players they've been doing this crap with for years?

I think everybody understands that it is frustrating for the person that added the fight to be left to die. But that person learned a lesson and can:

- come back with more people
- learn the names and expect this to happen.

I think it is as frustrating for people that add to see their realm mates stop fighting and let them die as it is for the realm mates to have a fun fight ruined by an adding realm mate.

Red is dead is not universal, it is one way to play the game. You just have to understand that not everybody likes to play that way.

It's not universal but is is the underlying these of this game, it always has been intended to be that way.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 6:34 PM by Forlornhope
opossum12 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 5:40 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 4:53 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

You basically just described people who have known each other for years, playing different realms, who pull off a fight with each other to let their realm mates die. And you really can't see how that would frustrate other people who are not part of their accepted group of other players they've been doing this crap with for years?

I think everybody understands that it is frustrating for the person that added the fight to be left to die. But that person learned a lesson and can:

- come back with more people
- learn the names and expect this to happen.

I think it is as frustrating for people that add to see their realm mates stop fighting and let them die as it is for the realm mates to have a fun fight ruined by an adding realm mate.

Red is dead is not universal, it is one way to play the game. You just have to understand that not everybody likes to play that way.

So a community who have known an played together for years who actively allow their friends kill members of the realm they are playing on, when does this become cross realming? Which IS against the rules.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:20 PM by Wolfir666
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

Jelly about people that kill solos and smallmen with ease, that kill random groups with ease, that whine when being killed by a zerg, and that run away, if what they call "fair fight" is not followed in their little world?

No, not really.. but you can continue to think that living on in your little lovely dream world, with just you and yourself and these little group of people you know for years :p
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:36 PM by Forlornhope
Wolfir666 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:20 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

Jelly about people that kill solos and smallmen with ease, that kill random groups with ease, that whine when being killed by a zerg, and that run away, if what they call "fair fight" is not followed in their little world?

No, not really.. but you can continue to think that living on in your little lovely dream world, with just you and yourself and these little group of people you know for years :p

Exactly, those same 8mans will add small man fights and 1v1s all day. Even some 8mans who aren't a member of their little community. I have no issue with people not wanting adds on their fights, in fact I don't add fights myself. I have more of an issue with the hypocrisy that these people exhibit. I can probably count on one hand the number of times that my fights have been left alone when one of these leet 8mans see it.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM by bigne88
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:36 PM
Wolfir666 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:20 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

Jelly about people that kill solos and smallmen with ease, that kill random groups with ease, that whine when being killed by a zerg, and that run away, if what they call "fair fight" is not followed in their little world?

No, not really.. but you can continue to think that living on in your little lovely dream world, with just you and yourself and these little group of people you know for years :p

Exactly, those same 8mans will add small man fights and 1v1s all day. Even some 8mans who aren't a member of their little community. I have no issue with people not wanting adds on their fights, in fact I don't add fights myself. I have more of an issue with the hypocrisy that these people exhibit. I can probably count on one hand the number of times that my fights have been left alone when one of these leet 8mans see it.

I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
How thous few players can turn you on like this?
Plus I dont see thous players venting here on the forum about getting zerged or added. Amirite?
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:42 PM by Forlornhope
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:36 PM
Wolfir666 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:20 PM
Jelly about people that kill solos and smallmen with ease, that kill random groups with ease, that whine when being killed by a zerg, and that run away, if what they call "fair fight" is not followed in their little world?

No, not really.. but you can continue to think that living on in your little lovely dream world, with just you and yourself and these little group of people you know for years :p

Exactly, those same 8mans will add small man fights and 1v1s all day. Even some 8mans who aren't a member of their little community. I have no issue with people not wanting adds on their fights, in fact I don't add fights myself. I have more of an issue with the hypocrisy that these people exhibit. I can probably count on one hand the number of times that my fights have been left alone when one of these leet 8mans see it.

I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
How thous few players can turn you on like this?
Plus I dont see thous players venting here on the forum about getting zerged or added. Amirite?

There are numerous posts on this forum with people complaining about being added, and a few in this actual thread. I don't get the other points you bring up though, sorry.
Mon 27 Jan 2020 11:12 PM by Wolfir666
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM
I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
[..]
or added.

Oh, i thought every party can contain up to 8 men.. or are you just talking about the friends you know and like to fight against with your 8man?
Mon 27 Jan 2020 11:37 PM by bigne88
Wolfir666 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 11:12 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM
I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
[..]
or added.

Oh, i thought every party can contain up to 8 men.. or are you just talking about the friends you know and like to fight against with your 8man?

Yea, was talking about the number of parties listed into the /gvg toggle
Mon 27 Jan 2020 11:50 PM by bigne88
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:42 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 8:36 PM
Exactly, those same 8mans will add small man fights and 1v1s all day. Even some 8mans who aren't a member of their little community. I have no issue with people not wanting adds on their fights, in fact I don't add fights myself. I have more of an issue with the hypocrisy that these people exhibit. I can probably count on one hand the number of times that my fights have been left alone when one of these leet 8mans see it.

I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
How thous few players can turn you on like this?
Plus I dont see thous players venting here on the forum about getting zerged or added. Amirite?

There are numerous posts on this forum with people complaining about being added, and a few in this actual thread. I don't get the other points you bring up though, sorry.

Dude, 8 men players solved the adding problem pulling off and killing adders.
No complains.

Btw I find miserable thous people that are hiding their lack of skill and party cohoordination behind the "red is dead, we should all band together to zerg the enemy".
If you are adding an ongoing party and die in the proces, it means that you played poorly and should aim on improving yourself instead of blaming your realm mates that were brave enough to fight the enemies by themself.

I don't wanna be rude, but there is nothing to moan about if you die against a stronger enemy.
A competitive minded person would think "i gotta improve so i can deafeat them". A lazy ass will think "next time i will bring more friends".

Both ways works, just accept your defeat and dont moan, release and come back.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 12:08 AM by Forlornhope
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 11:50 PM
Forlornhope wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:42 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 10:19 PM
I can count on one hand the number of 8 men party outside during primetime.
How thous few players can turn you on like this?
Plus I dont see thous players venting here on the forum about getting zerged or added. Amirite?

There are numerous posts on this forum with people complaining about being added, and a few in this actual thread. I don't get the other points you bring up though, sorry.

Dude, 8 men players solved the adding problem pulling off and killing adders.
No complains.

Btw I find miserable thous people that are hiding their lack of skill and party cohoordination behind the "red is dead, we should all band together to zerg the enemy".
If you are adding an ongoing party and die in the proces, it means that you played poorly and should aim on improving yourself instead of blaming your realm mates that were brave enough to fight the enemies by themself.

I don't wanna be rude, but there is nothing to moan about if you die against a stronger enemy.
A competitive minded person would think "i gotta improve so i can deafeat them". A lazy ass will think "next time i will bring more friends".

Both ways works, just accept your defeat and dont moan, release and come back.

I don't have a problem with the no adding mentality, I have an issue with the vast majority of those players who break off when someone adds their fights but has zero problems adding other people's. The people who they don't add are generally their small group of other 8man only players who they all know. As I stated before I don't add people's fights, but I have an issue getting added by these people who then go break off and let the group they were fighting kill their realm mates for adding there fights. I see people do this shit all the time, and so do the vast majority of other people in this thread.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 12:54 AM by gotwqqd
Allowing realm mates to die goes against the spirit of the game. Those who think otherwise are selfish deniers
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:05 AM by opossum12
gotwqqd wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 12:54 AM
Allowing realm mates to die goes against the spirit of the game. Those who think otherwise are selfish deniers

Onstill don't understand why people are trying tonwin the argument? You want people that pull off fights when added to be banned?
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:24 AM by gotwqqd
opossum12 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:05 AM
gotwqqd wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 12:54 AM
Allowing realm mates to die goes against the spirit of the game. Those who think otherwise are selfish deniers

Onstill don't understand why people are trying tonwin the argument? You want people that pull off fights when added to be banned?
No
Though it probably is not going to occur, I want them to treat them as allies and kill the enemy and HOPE that in future they get clean fights. If they do, so be it and more power to them. Realm mates should be higher priority than their precious “even” fights
Tue 28 Jan 2020 3:38 AM by Quik
gotwqqd wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:24 AM
Though it probably is not going to occur, I want them to treat them as allies and kill the enemy and HOPE that in future they get clean fights. If they do, so be it and more power to them. Realm mates should be higher priority than their precious “even” fights

This is how it should be, and it is sad it will never be this way again.

I would rather have 10 realm mates add on any fight I am in, and in the process tell me that my realm stands with me, then this stupid "skilled" argument that people want to throw around.

This is a freakin realm vs realm game not a "my skill is better then yours". There are only a few "elite" players in the game, followed by a bunch of good players, followed by a multitude of average players. The elite and the good love to act like the game is about how "they" want to play and not about how your realm is playing.

As far as the "red is dead" philosophy, I wish a dev would chime in on this, but "red is dead" is a DAoC staple, not a server specific idea. The entire consecpt of DAoC is built around "red is dead" which is WHY the game is a realm vs realm vs realm.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:15 AM by bigne88
gotwqqd wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:24 AM
opossum12 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:05 AM
gotwqqd wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 12:54 AM
Allowing realm mates to die goes against the spirit of the game. Those who think otherwise are selfish deniers

Onstill don't understand why people are trying tonwin the argument? You want people that pull off fights when added to be banned?
No
Though it probably is not going to occur, I want them to treat them as allies and kill the enemy and HOPE that in future they get clean fights. If they do, so be it and more power to them. Realm mates should be higher priority than their precious “even” fights

You might be right, but remember that if you zerg an enemy, once, a second time...the third time he will log off frustrated.
As a daoc private server, do we have the luxury to make people quit? Look at all the fuss with the UStz mid zerg.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 8:30 AM by Lux.Thoras
I bet my butt that everyone who whines about pulling out of the fight and let others die, is doing the same thing.
When you see a smallmen being jumped by an 8men, most run away instead of helping the smallmen.
That's exactly the same, because actually, Red is Dead and you have to do it.

This 2 class mentality here is so crazy. Always judge and judge others, but never start with yourself.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 8:44 AM by Wolfir666
Lux.Thoras wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 8:30 AM
I bet my butt that everyone who whines about pulling out of the fight and let others die, is doing the same thing.
When you see a smallmen being jumped by an 8men, most run away instead of helping the smallmen.
That's exactly the same, because actually, Red is Dead and you have to do it.

This 2 class mentality here is so crazy. Always judge and judge others, but never start with yourself.

Uhm, of course it is not the same:

If you run away, because you think you will lose the fight, as you are fewer in numbers, then that also can help to amass and return again with more people, won't work if you fight a losing fight.
If you run away, because you think you will *win* the fight, and just don't want to win it like that and want to teach the adding people a lesson, that came to help you, well.....

I guess everybody will see a difference in these things, don't you agree?

Because that's the thing, these 8men do that "to teach a lesson" to their realm-mates, what is totally silly in itself anyways.
Because they want others, to hold on to their rules and want to punish those realm-mates, that don't.

Edit:
And there is the difference:
1) You run away to avoid losing, thus strengthening the realm with not granting the enemy too much RP and coming back in larger numbers, to beat the enemies up.
2) You run away to avoid winning, thus letting your realm-mates die and thus strenghtening the enemy realm with granting them the RP and not to your own realm.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 1:18 PM by Lux.Thoras
Wolfir666 wrote: Edit:
And there is the difference:
1) You run away to avoid losing, thus strengthening the realm with not granting the enemy too much RP and coming back in larger numbers, to beat the enemies up.
2) You run away to avoid winning, thus letting your realm-mates die and thus strenghtening the enemy realm with granting them the RP and not to your own realm.

To your no 1:
How do you identify that the smallmen will not win with your help? If you would help, possibly some others (stealthers) would also help. We had several fights as small men vs. a full group and we lost closely.
I know why, you clearly want to outnumber the enemy, you want a sure victory.
That is the fact. That is why this whole discussion is ongoing.
If something is against you or prevents you from winning, it is: either bad, it does not comply with the server rules (or let's say how you interpret the rules), destroys your fun or forces you to play differently.


To your no 2:
Did you ever think about the possibility that the main target can be something different then only "winning"?

When we fight against another group and we lose, but we gave everything, I feel ok even if I lost the fight.
Because they were able to win through their skills in a balanced situation.
To clarify what I am talking about: I talk about respect to others, respect on their skill to play this GAME. To honor their success and how they want to play.
If someone adds into the fight, yes, it is unlucky, but I do not blame or flame him, because it is his way to play.

Do you really think the 8men will force you to play how they want?
What is then the Zerg doing? -> I know, Zerg is the Game, Read is Dead.

If I read your text and some others:
I always read “Red is Dead”, “Crossrealm”, “Against the rules”. Those Topics are used to cover the real points.
I want to win, I want to have fun, I..I..I. Don´t care about others. RED IS DEAD.

You forget something, behind your RED IS DEAD targets. There are also people playing this game which also want´s to have fun. Also, it could be that they play once a week in your realm, on the other day in the other realm. What´s about those which are switching between the realms during the week? Are they always and everywhere “RED IS DEAD”? Why is it allowed to switch between the realms if there is a rule to play only for the realm?

I know that there are players in groups flaming others for adding and this is not ok. Compared to all groups, I would say this is only a small number of groups / players.
Blaming all of them is from my point of view not OK.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM by bigne88
Red is dead? Reasonable
People adding against or with you stealing your fun, RP and glory? Frustrating.

I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

8 men players like me are putting a lot of effort to improve their skills, change party meta, cultivating friendship to form a party with nice and good people.
I have, as most of people playing daoc, since we are all above 30+, limited time to play and I will do my best to enjoy every moment of this hobby and if people are trying to grief my way of having fun, well, yea, I will pull off, focus the adders and respect other's 8v8 and 1v1 as well, because I'm sure that the guy playing from another part of the world is trying to enjoy his time as well, so he will keep logging and play with/against me.

Thia is, for me, the sportmanship. Respect each other's time invested in this hobby.

You wanna big fights and kill everything that moves? Join a BG and enjoy! Easy as fuck
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:29 PM by gotwqqd
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM
Red is dead? Reasonable
People adding against or with you stealing your fun, RP and glory? Frustrating.

I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

8 men players like me are putting a lot of effort to improve their skills, change party meta, cultivating friendship to form a party with nice and good people.
I have, as most of people playing daoc, since we are all above 30+, limited time to play and I will do my best to enjoy every moment of this hobby and if people are trying to grief my way of having fun, well, yea, I will pull off, focus the adders and respect other's 8v8 and 1v1 as well, because I'm sure that the guy playing from another part of the world is trying to enjoy his time as well, so he will keep logging and play with/against me.

Thia is, for me, the sportmanship. Respect each other's time invested in this hobby.

You wanna big fights and kill everything that moves? Join a BG and enjoy! Easy as fuck
Griefing??!!!!

Haha haha
What a laugh
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:43 PM by Wolfir666
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM
I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

I see...

So helping a Realm-Mate against the enemy Realm is griefing.
And not helping a realm-mate against the enemy realm is sportmanship.

Yes.. makes perfect sense.. dream on.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:56 PM by MrWolf
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM
Red is dead? Reasonable
People adding against or with you stealing your fun, RP and glory? Frustrating.

I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

8 men players like me are putting a lot of effort to improve their skills, change party meta, cultivating friendship to form a party with nice and good people.
I have, as most of people playing daoc, since we are all above 30+, limited time to play and I will do my best to enjoy every moment of this hobby and if people are trying to grief my way of having fun, well, yea, I will pull off, focus the adders and respect other's 8v8 and 1v1 as well, because I'm sure that the guy playing from another part of the world is trying to enjoy his time as well, so he will keep logging and play with/against me.

Thia is, for me, the sportmanship. Respect each other's time invested in this hobby.

You wanna big fights and kill everything that moves? Join a BG and enjoy! Easy as fuck

Ain't war hell? (cit.)
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:28 PM by bigne88
Wolfir666 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:43 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM
I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

I see...

So helping a Realm-Mate against the enemy Realm is griefing.
And not helping a realm-mate against the enemy realm is sportmanship.

Yes.. makes perfect sense.. dream on.

Who says your realm mates needs help?
I prefer dying after a long and hard fight instead of winning an eazymode one. Call me egoist, but I dont wanna share my hard earned RPs and fun with a random griefer passing trough.

And in the scenario where your real mates apreciated your help, what do you think the enemy players will do, after being zerged? Disband, log off and get some fresh air or come back?

Your miopy is unbelivable.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:30 PM by Riac
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:28 PM
Wolfir666 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:43 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 7:58 PM
I'm an average member of the 8v8 comunity and for me adding is a form of griefing.
The people adding are thinking between themself "mmm easy RP to be made! Lets grief on thous reds without any kind of effort!"

I see...

So helping a Realm-Mate against the enemy Realm is griefing.
And not helping a realm-mate against the enemy realm is sportmanship.

Yes.. makes perfect sense.. dream on.

Who says your realm mates needs help?
I prefer dying after a long and hard fight instead of winning an eazymode one. Call me egoist, but I dont wanna share my hard earned RPs and fun with a random griefer passing trough.

one of my favorite things in the world is when someone adds on my 1v1 and i just run away and my realm mate, with all his sportsmanship, gets his dumbass whipped lol.
then i dont even finish the kill to give them rps. i love that sooooo much.
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:32 PM by bigne88
Riac wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:30 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 11:28 PM
Wolfir666 wrote:
Tue 28 Jan 2020 10:43 PM
I see...

So helping a Realm-Mate against the enemy Realm is griefing.
And not helping a realm-mate against the enemy realm is sportmanship.

Yes.. makes perfect sense.. dream on.

Who says your realm mates needs help?
I prefer dying after a long and hard fight instead of winning an eazymode one. Call me egoist, but I dont wanna share my hard earned RPs and fun with a random griefer passing trough.

one of my favorite things in the world is when someone adds on my 1v1 and i just run away and my realm mate, with all his sportsmanship, gets his dumbass whipped lol.
then i dont even finish the kill to give them rps. i love that sooooo much.

Exactly!
Wed 29 Jan 2020 8:50 AM by Sepplord
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

This is really a heavy misrepresentation on the situation. It's also quite ironic you claim they can control the situation despite being outnumbered...because why does the other group pull off then? They are, apparently, NOT able to deal with it. So they rely on the rest of their enemies pulling off so they can fight 8vs 2-6. It is never the group that is about to lose that pulls of.

If they know each other so well, why are they initiating fights at docks/portkeeps? Wouldn't it be really easy to roam far away zones and EV? With the bonus that there would be very few adds? This question always gets dodged.

When our smallmen sees another smallman near docks, we run somewhere else before fighting. Why is that not possible for the 8men that are so skilled, coordinated AND know each other for years? The reason is, because the 8men mainly are looking to farm RPs. It would be stupid easy to have one clean 8vs8 after another in a remote area. But that doesn't give that feeling of superiority.
Wed 29 Jan 2020 9:37 AM by Kimahri
LOL @ all these plebs talking about realm pride in 2020, especially on a server with 4 hour realm swap timer and GVG/fairfight commands built into the game. Nice try kids
Wed 29 Jan 2020 9:59 AM by Wolfir666
Kimahri wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 9:37 AM
kids

If only :p

Or are those, that call others kids, more likely to be kids?
We never will know... :p
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:13 PM by bigne88
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 8:50 AM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

This is really a heavy misrepresentation on the situation. It's also quite ironic you claim they can control the situation despite being outnumbered...because why does the other group pull off then? They are, apparently, NOT able to deal with it. So they rely on the rest of their enemies pulling off so they can fight 8vs 2-6. It is never the group that is about to lose that pulls of.

If they know each other so well, why are they initiating fights at docks/portkeeps? Wouldn't it be really easy to roam far away zones and EV? With the bonus that there would be very few adds? This question always gets dodged.

When our smallmen sees another smallman near docks, we run somewhere else before fighting. Why is that not possible for the 8men that are so skilled, coordinated AND know each other for years? The reason is, because the 8men mainly are looking to farm RPs. It would be stupid easy to have one clean 8vs8 after another in a remote area. But that doesn't give that feeling of superiority.

You might be surprised and deluded but a majority of the 8v8 clean fight thing resolve themself around ev or the various realm's maze area, depending on teleports.

The problem emerge when:
1. 8men party are really few and if you dont have another party to fight against, it is always fun to taunt the enemy zerg and try your kiting skills. So you will see 8men party roaming around the most active areas.

2. EV, sadly, generate massive lag or fps drops, I still dont understand wich one. I read somewhere that it is caused from the old Agramon map laying under the EV pixels and your PC has to load both.

3. Teleports that force choke points.


To farm RPs you do small men and camp docks.
Also 8 men pull out from busiest area, usually. When they sit around docks it meana they are going to pull the zerg.
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:40 PM by opossum12
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 8:50 AM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

This is really a heavy misrepresentation on the situation. It's also quite ironic you claim they can control the situation despite being outnumbered...because why does the other group pull off then? They are, apparently, NOT able to deal with it. So they rely on the rest of their enemies pulling off so they can fight 8vs 2-6. It is never the group that is about to lose that pulls of.

If they know each other so well, why are they initiating fights at docks/portkeeps? Wouldn't it be really easy to roam far away zones and EV? With the bonus that there would be very few adds? This question always gets dodged.

When our smallmen sees another smallman near docks, we run somewhere else before fighting. Why is that not possible for the 8men that are so skilled, coordinated AND know each other for years? The reason is, because the 8men mainly are looking to farm RPs. It would be stupid easy to have one clean 8vs8 after another in a remote area. But that doesn't give that feeling of superiority.


I'm not sure what you are trying to say in the first part. Usually, an 8v8 that gets added goes like this :

- Fight starts as 8v8.
- One group starts getting the upper hand on the other group
- A smallman adds one of the two groups.
- The group that now has the numbers advantage usually sees that their opponents have adds
- They pull off and let them deal with the adds.
- When pulling off, if they were losing they take the opportunity to rez-rebuff and regen. If they were winning they just wait.
- Once the adds have been taken care of, the groups will usually let the other rez/rebuff
- They can decide to either pull off and fight again in 2-3 minutes, or they just go at it again.

So it's not about who's losing pulls off or whatever.

This also depends on who you are fighting. If you are fighting a good group, you'll usually need them to pull off to be able to deal with adds. If it's just a solo stealther you can usually focus him and blap him within 2-3 seconds. If it's a smallman with heals and cc it's more complicated.

If you are fighting a region pug (and you are in a good group), you can usually deal with adds without too much problem by just re-positionning and killing adds.

As for fighting location, EV is laggy as hell. I know when I go there I get massive ping issues and just ghost all over the place. The zone is there but you can't actually play there.

From experience, the fights take place where the other 8 mans can get back to the zone quickly after a death. That's usually going to be around DC/Beno/Bled and the mazes.

I feel the topic of the thread swapped from someone complaining about getting killed when adding an 8v8 fight into 8 mans are complaining about adds, which can be the case but wasn't the original topic of the thread.
Wed 29 Jan 2020 2:54 PM by MrWolf
opossum12 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:40 PM
From experience, the fights take place where the other 8 mans can get back to the zone quickly after a death. That's usually going to be around DC/Beno/Bled and the mazes.

LOL
Wed 29 Jan 2020 3:25 PM by Sepplord
opossum12 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:40 PM
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 8:50 AM
bigne88 wrote:
Mon 27 Jan 2020 12:40 PM
I think that most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added.

If thous cohordinated players understand that they cant win what shall they do? Stay and die or pull out and give the other 8 men honorable party a chance to faight again later in a fair situation?

8 men comunity is small and knows each other from years and fought each other on different servers on different realms. After years and years of knowing each other it came out a nice sportmanship that to neophites can seems lime elitarism circlejerkimg.

This is really a heavy misrepresentation on the situation. It's also quite ironic you claim they can control the situation despite being outnumbered...because why does the other group pull off then? They are, apparently, NOT able to deal with it. So they rely on the rest of their enemies pulling off so they can fight 8vs 2-6. It is never the group that is about to lose that pulls of.

If they know each other so well, why are they initiating fights at docks/portkeeps? Wouldn't it be really easy to roam far away zones and EV? With the bonus that there would be very few adds? This question always gets dodged.

When our smallmen sees another smallman near docks, we run somewhere else before fighting. Why is that not possible for the 8men that are so skilled, coordinated AND know each other for years? The reason is, because the 8men mainly are looking to farm RPs. It would be stupid easy to have one clean 8vs8 after another in a remote area. But that doesn't give that feeling of superiority.


I'm not sure what you are trying to say in the first part. Usually, an 8v8 that gets added goes like this :

- Fight starts as 8v8.
- One group starts getting the upper hand on the other group
- A smallman adds one of the two groups.
- The group that now has the numbers advantage usually sees that their opponents have adds
- They pull off and let them deal with the adds.
- When pulling off, if they were losing they take the opportunity to rez-rebuff and regen. If they were winning they just wait.
- Once the adds have been taken care of, the groups will usually let the other rez/rebuff
- They can decide to either pull off and fight again in 2-3 minutes, or they just go at it again.

So it's not about who's losing pulls off or whatever.

Exactly the point i was making. It was in direct response to the previous comment i quoted in the response and now in this reply for easier acces. Bigne88 makes a few claims there that are utterly ridicolous. The two biggest ones were which i adressed:

a) That "most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added" (obvioulsy they don't otherwise noone would have to pull off...seems like we agree here that the claim is ridiculous)

b) That the decision the group has to make is between "Stay and die or pull out" which is also just misleading since the group that does the pulling out, is NOT the group that's about to lose. The decision is "fight and zerg my friends that i randomly met on the highway for a chilled fight between just us" or "pull out and let my friends farm another batch of random soloers. Mostly soloers that they have been farming for the last ten minutes not letting them to their dock. They went into hiding after getting farmed a lot and are now coming out again because they think we will help against the enemies...teehee suckers"


We can sugarcoat it more, but in the end it's a dickmove. No matter how you turn it. When you run your 8man around the docks and farm smallmen/solos, then you are not looking for cleanfights. Any good 8man will without problem kill loads and loads of soloers/smallmen at a dock. The chance that none of them will add an 8vs8 is basically zero. So any 8-men trying to cleanfight at docks/portkeeps is either not as smart as they claim (unlikely...i bet they are all aware) or they are intentionally starting the fight knowing that they will have to pull off and "let the other group defend themselves" *cough cough*
Wed 29 Jan 2020 10:45 PM by bigne88
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 3:25 PM
opossum12 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:40 PM
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 8:50 AM
This is really a heavy misrepresentation on the situation. It's also quite ironic you claim they can control the situation despite being outnumbered...because why does the other group pull off then? They are, apparently, NOT able to deal with it. So they rely on the rest of their enemies pulling off so they can fight 8vs 2-6. It is never the group that is about to lose that pulls of.

If they know each other so well, why are they initiating fights at docks/portkeeps? Wouldn't it be really easy to roam far away zones and EV? With the bonus that there would be very few adds? This question always gets dodged.

When our smallmen sees another smallman near docks, we run somewhere else before fighting. Why is that not possible for the 8men that are so skilled, coordinated AND know each other for years? The reason is, because the 8men mainly are looking to farm RPs. It would be stupid easy to have one clean 8vs8 after another in a remote area. But that doesn't give that feeling of superiority.


I'm not sure what you are trying to say in the first part. Usually, an 8v8 that gets added goes like this :

- Fight starts as 8v8.
- One group starts getting the upper hand on the other group
- A smallman adds one of the two groups.
- The group that now has the numbers advantage usually sees that their opponents have adds
- They pull off and let them deal with the adds.
- When pulling off, if they were losing they take the opportunity to rez-rebuff and regen. If they were winning they just wait.
- Once the adds have been taken care of, the groups will usually let the other rez/rebuff
- They can decide to either pull off and fight again in 2-3 minutes, or they just go at it again.

So it's not about who's losing pulls off or whatever.

Exactly the point i was making. It was in direct response to the previous comment i quoted in the response and now in this reply for easier acces. Bigne88 makes a few claims there that are utterly ridicolous. The two biggest ones were which i adressed:

a) That "most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added" (obvioulsy they don't otherwise noone would have to pull off...seems like we agree here that the claim is ridiculous)

b) That the decision the group has to make is between "Stay and die or pull out" which is also just misleading since the group that does the pulling out, is NOT the group that's about to lose. The decision is "fight and zerg my friends that i randomly met on the highway for a chilled fight between just us" or "pull out and let my friends farm another batch of random soloers. Mostly soloers that they have been farming for the last ten minutes not letting them to their dock. They went into hiding after getting farmed a lot and are now coming out again because they think we will help against the enemies...teehee suckers"


We can sugarcoat it more, but in the end it's a dickmove. No matter how you turn it. When you run your 8man around the docks and farm smallmen/solos, then you are not looking for cleanfights. Any good 8man will without problem kill loads and loads of soloers/smallmen at a dock. The chance that none of them will add an 8vs8 is basically zero. So any 8-men trying to cleanfight at docks/portkeeps is either not as smart as they claim (unlikely...i bet they are all aware) or they are intentionally starting the fight knowing that they will have to pull off and "let the other group defend themselves" *cough cough*

Sorry m8, no offence, but you really have no idea of what you are talking about because you have zero experience in 8v8.

Listen this: soloers, shitty useless stealthers, small men, full group and zergs have 100% rights and freedom to add an 8v8, ok?
Otherhand 8v8 players have the freedom to react to this adders in any possible way.

You have the freedom to add me? SURE, but I have the freedom to pull off or focus on you.

Cmon man, aint hard to understand! You cant come here and teach me how to play daoc right or wrong. I have the freedom to pull off anytime I want and focus the target that I please the most.
If a scout pops and start adding my fight, I have the freedom to insta collapse on him, pulling off fight, and delete him. I wont stand still and letting him greefing on me.

I know that my english is awfull, but it shouldnt be hard to understand. Unless you are a stealther player...this would explain a lot.
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM by gotwqqd
bigne88 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 10:45 PM
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 3:25 PM
opossum12 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 1:40 PM
I'm not sure what you are trying to say in the first part. Usually, an 8v8 that gets added goes like this :

- Fight starts as 8v8.
- One group starts getting the upper hand on the other group
- A smallman adds one of the two groups.
- The group that now has the numbers advantage usually sees that their opponents have adds
- They pull off and let them deal with the adds.
- When pulling off, if they were losing they take the opportunity to rez-rebuff and regen. If they were winning they just wait.
- Once the adds have been taken care of, the groups will usually let the other rez/rebuff
- They can decide to either pull off and fight again in 2-3 minutes, or they just go at it again.

So it's not about who's losing pulls off or whatever.

Exactly the point i was making. It was in direct response to the previous comment i quoted in the response and now in this reply for easier acces. Bigne88 makes a few claims there that are utterly ridicolous. The two biggest ones were which i adressed:

a) That "most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added" (obvioulsy they don't otherwise noone would have to pull off...seems like we agree here that the claim is ridiculous)

b) That the decision the group has to make is between "Stay and die or pull out" which is also just misleading since the group that does the pulling out, is NOT the group that's about to lose. The decision is "fight and zerg my friends that i randomly met on the highway for a chilled fight between just us" or "pull out and let my friends farm another batch of random soloers. Mostly soloers that they have been farming for the last ten minutes not letting them to their dock. They went into hiding after getting farmed a lot and are now coming out again because they think we will help against the enemies...teehee suckers"


We can sugarcoat it more, but in the end it's a dickmove. No matter how you turn it. When you run your 8man around the docks and farm smallmen/solos, then you are not looking for cleanfights. Any good 8man will without problem kill loads and loads of soloers/smallmen at a dock. The chance that none of them will add an 8vs8 is basically zero. So any 8-men trying to cleanfight at docks/portkeeps is either not as smart as they claim (unlikely...i bet they are all aware) or they are intentionally starting the fight knowing that they will have to pull off and "let the other group defend themselves" *cough cough*

Sorry m8, no offence, but you really have no idea of what you are talking about because you have zero experience in 8v8.

Listen this: soloers, shitty useless stealthers, small men, full group and zergs have 100% rights and freedom to add an 8v8, ok?
Otherhand 8v8 players have the freedom to react to this adders in any possible way.

You have the freedom to add me? SURE, but I have the freedom to pull off or focus on you.

Cmon man, aint hard to understand! You cant come here and teach me how to play daoc right or wrong. I have the freedom to pull off anytime I want and focus the target that I please the most.
If a scout pops and start adding my fight, I have the freedom to insta collapse on him, pulling off fight, and delete him. I wont stand still and letting him greefing on me.

I know that my english is awfull, but it shouldnt be hard to understand. Unless you are a stealther player...this would explain a lot.
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die
Thu 30 Jan 2020 11:54 AM by bigne88
gotwqqd wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 10:45 PM
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 3:25 PM
Exactly the point i was making. It was in direct response to the previous comment i quoted in the response and now in this reply for easier acces. Bigne88 makes a few claims there that are utterly ridicolous. The two biggest ones were which i adressed:

a) That "most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added" (obvioulsy they don't otherwise noone would have to pull off...seems like we agree here that the claim is ridiculous)

b) That the decision the group has to make is between "Stay and die or pull out" which is also just misleading since the group that does the pulling out, is NOT the group that's about to lose. The decision is "fight and zerg my friends that i randomly met on the highway for a chilled fight between just us" or "pull out and let my friends farm another batch of random soloers. Mostly soloers that they have been farming for the last ten minutes not letting them to their dock. They went into hiding after getting farmed a lot and are now coming out again because they think we will help against the enemies...teehee suckers"


We can sugarcoat it more, but in the end it's a dickmove. No matter how you turn it. When you run your 8man around the docks and farm smallmen/solos, then you are not looking for cleanfights. Any good 8man will without problem kill loads and loads of soloers/smallmen at a dock. The chance that none of them will add an 8vs8 is basically zero. So any 8-men trying to cleanfight at docks/portkeeps is either not as smart as they claim (unlikely...i bet they are all aware) or they are intentionally starting the fight knowing that they will have to pull off and "let the other group defend themselves" *cough cough*

Sorry m8, no offence, but you really have no idea of what you are talking about because you have zero experience in 8v8.

Listen this: soloers, shitty useless stealthers, small men, full group and zergs have 100% rights and freedom to add an 8v8, ok?
Otherhand 8v8 players have the freedom to react to this adders in any possible way.

You have the freedom to add me? SURE, but I have the freedom to pull off or focus on you.

Cmon man, aint hard to understand! You cant come here and teach me how to play daoc right or wrong. I have the freedom to pull off anytime I want and focus the target that I please the most.
If a scout pops and start adding my fight, I have the freedom to insta collapse on him, pulling off fight, and delete him. I wont stand still and letting him greefing on me.

I know that my english is awfull, but it shouldnt be hard to understand. Unless you are a stealther player...this would explain a lot.
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die

We are talking about a videogame, not real life! Where it is written that I have to stop by to help someone against my interest? How many times have you run away leaving behind your comrades?

Call me egoist and selfish, but I play for fun, sometimes for RPs, not to play "red cross online".
Thu 30 Jan 2020 1:09 PM by Razur Ur
If you want to have pure 8vs8 without add's then please run in EV and plz tell me not about shitty lags! Only on entrance from EV get everyone short a lag but not in the middle from EV. The most SG´s with 8vs8 intention on this server running in the zerg frontier zone only for RP´s RP´s and more RP´s and not for looking around nice 8vs8!

I see every day some SG´s or called self Elite Pro Player which are looking for nice Fights on the frontkeep from DC/BENO/Bled and farming solo´s and smallgroups.
this is the reason for most random groups to adding nice 8vs8 fights because of no respect from 8vs8 players for solo/smallman and causalplayer. On live
Server/Cluster was the respect greater in the 8vs8 Community and not so toxic how on this freeshard server phönix.
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM by inoeth
gotwqqd wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 10:45 PM
Sepplord wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 3:25 PM
Exactly the point i was making. It was in direct response to the previous comment i quoted in the response and now in this reply for easier acces. Bigne88 makes a few claims there that are utterly ridicolous. The two biggest ones were which i adressed:

a) That "most people are jelly about this few 8v8 players who has the skill and ability to controll the situation when outnumberd or added" (obvioulsy they don't otherwise noone would have to pull off...seems like we agree here that the claim is ridiculous)

b) That the decision the group has to make is between "Stay and die or pull out" which is also just misleading since the group that does the pulling out, is NOT the group that's about to lose. The decision is "fight and zerg my friends that i randomly met on the highway for a chilled fight between just us" or "pull out and let my friends farm another batch of random soloers. Mostly soloers that they have been farming for the last ten minutes not letting them to their dock. They went into hiding after getting farmed a lot and are now coming out again because they think we will help against the enemies...teehee suckers"


We can sugarcoat it more, but in the end it's a dickmove. No matter how you turn it. When you run your 8man around the docks and farm smallmen/solos, then you are not looking for cleanfights. Any good 8man will without problem kill loads and loads of soloers/smallmen at a dock. The chance that none of them will add an 8vs8 is basically zero. So any 8-men trying to cleanfight at docks/portkeeps is either not as smart as they claim (unlikely...i bet they are all aware) or they are intentionally starting the fight knowing that they will have to pull off and "let the other group defend themselves" *cough cough*

Sorry m8, no offence, but you really have no idea of what you are talking about because you have zero experience in 8v8.

Listen this: soloers, shitty useless stealthers, small men, full group and zergs have 100% rights and freedom to add an 8v8, ok?
Otherhand 8v8 players have the freedom to react to this adders in any possible way.

You have the freedom to add me? SURE, but I have the freedom to pull off or focus on you.

Cmon man, aint hard to understand! You cant come here and teach me how to play daoc right or wrong. I have the freedom to pull off anytime I want and focus the target that I please the most.
If a scout pops and start adding my fight, I have the freedom to insta collapse on him, pulling off fight, and delete him. I wont stand still and letting him greefing on me.

I know that my english is awfull, but it shouldnt be hard to understand. Unless you are a stealther player...this would explain a lot.
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die

lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:39 AM by gotwqqd
inoeth wrote:
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM
gotwqqd wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 10:45 PM
Sorry m8, no offence, but you really have no idea of what you are talking about because you have zero experience in 8v8.

Listen this: soloers, shitty useless stealthers, small men, full group and zergs have 100% rights and freedom to add an 8v8, ok?
Otherhand 8v8 players have the freedom to react to this adders in any possible way.

You have the freedom to add me? SURE, but I have the freedom to pull off or focus on you.

Cmon man, aint hard to understand! You cant come here and teach me how to play daoc right or wrong. I have the freedom to pull off anytime I want and focus the target that I please the most.
If a scout pops and start adding my fight, I have the freedom to insta collapse on him, pulling off fight, and delete him. I wont stand still and letting him greefing on me.

I know that my english is awfull, but it shouldnt be hard to understand. Unless you are a stealther player...this would explain a lot.
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die

lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Wow
Your self centered mentality is mind boggling.

My bet... if the developers were able to somehow stop this practice they would. It’s just not possible. If we asked the game’s creator I’d bet he said your pathetic practice is against the spirit of the game.
Fri 31 Jan 2020 7:16 AM by bigne88
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:39 AM
inoeth wrote:
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM
gotwqqd wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die

lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Wow
Your self centered mentality is mind boggling.

My bet... if the developers were able to somehow stop this practice they would. It’s just not possible. If we asked the game’s creator I’d bet he said your pathetic practice is against the spirit of the game.

"The spirit of the game". Good stuff you smoking.
A server with 4 hours swap and a custom /gvg toggle command...what you talking about. Devs here have done great things to incentivate both zerg and solo, small, 8v8.
Fri 31 Jan 2020 7:23 AM by inoeth
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:39 AM
inoeth wrote:
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM
gotwqqd wrote:
Wed 29 Jan 2020 11:25 PM
Most of the argument isn’t about focusing on an enemy add. But about leaving a realm mate to die

lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Wow
Your self centered mentality is mind boggling.

My bet... if the developers were able to somehow stop this practice they would. It’s just not possible. If we asked the game’s creator I’d bet he said your pathetic practice is against the spirit of the game.

you seem to forget that the toons you are playing with and against are actually people. people play this game to have fun and for some players like me 1v1 and 8v8 is fun. then there are people like you who want to destroy our fun. do you think we put up with it? no! we destroy your fun, till you learn to let us play like we want it. why dont you guys not just go to the zerg zones and let us be?
my bet you are the ones who got bullied in school and now want to give it back somehow.... i have zero sympathy for that behavior.

live and let live
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:06 AM by lolmatron
oldmanukko wrote:
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM
“Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”
― Mahatma Gandhi

/\
|
|
Possibly the only thing that could improve the non-zerg quality of life on this server....

Doesnt matter how/why/where people add on others fights, if you are out in the FZs you have chosen to participated in RvR. Deal with it!
If you let realmmates die because they added or whatever, call it roleplay or tactics and its fine. Griefplay cannot really be applied since it's in the FZs, where it is simply "survival of the fitest".

Considering the problem at hand for these elite players....
Give these hardcore diehards another option other than running the docks and coasts?
## Why not make EV the only zone where you can use the GvG command, with a increase in bonus? Add a command for smallmans aswell, for another zone.. And throw the solos a bone aswell....
## 8v8, 5v5 and 1v1 Arenas could do, with a king of the hill type of ruleset - winner stays in the arena until defeated or won 10 in a row... And a shorter cooldown before beeing able to queue again, to allow other challengers the chance. And debuff those that rage quit or leave the arena, something like -95% rps for 5hours.

Worst part is that no one outside these setgrps/smallmen get a chance to compete, thats the nature of a 15+year old game. Some of these guys/girls have played as one unit for 10+ years. The best and simplest solution would be for these grps to get of thier highhorses and start rolling in PUGS, teaching and sharing playstyle and approach. THIS might increase the amount of random 8mans/smalls running around - which in-turn increases action in each department - could in the end reduce zerg numbers. But as it stands: you try to go out as 8man/smalls, and the only other grps you meet are rr10+ ones that have played for ages as one. This problem is nothing new, it plauges all the servers (freeshard or not)..

I would love to do pug 8v8 and be able to face-off with another pug. But as it is now it's difficult.. and time is short (cant spend 1h+ to setup grp only to be able to run afew times). The golden pug-8man-pre-ToA-days are loong gone.....
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:19 AM by inoeth
lolmatron wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:06 AM
oldmanukko wrote:
Sat 25 Jan 2020 4:14 PM
“Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”
― Mahatma Gandhi

/\
|
|
Possibly the only thing that could improve the non-zerg quality of life on this server....

Doesnt matter how/why/where people add on others fights, if you are out in the FZs you have chosen to participated in RvR. Deal with it!
If you let realmmates die because they added or whatever, call it roleplay or tactics and its fine. Griefplay cannot really be applied since it's in the FZs, where it is simply "survival of the fitest".

Considering the problem at hand for these elite players....
Give these hardcore diehards another option other than running the docks and coasts?
## Why not make EV the only zone where you can use the GvG command, with a increase in bonus? Add a command for smallmans aswell, for another zone.. And throw the solos a bone aswell....
## 8v8, 5v5 and 1v1 Arenas could do, with a king of the hill type of ruleset - winner stays in the arena until defeated or won 10 in a row... And a shorter cooldown before beeing able to queue again, to allow other challengers the chance. And debuff those that rage quit or leave the arena, something like -95% rps for 5hours.

Worst part is that no one outside these setgrps/smallmen get a chance to compete, thats the nature of a 15+year old game. Some of these guys/girls have played as one unit for 10+ years. The best and simplest solution would be for these grps to get of thier highhorses and start rolling in PUGS, teaching and sharing playstyle and approach. THIS might increase the amount of random 8mans/smalls running around - which in-turn increases action in each department - could in the end reduce zerg numbers. But as it stands: you try to go out as 8man/smalls, and the only other grps you meet are rr10+ ones that have played for ages as one. This problem is nothing new, it plauges all the servers (freeshard or not)..

I would love to do pug 8v8 and be able to face-off with another pug. But as it is now it's difficult.. and time is short (cant spend 1h+ to setup grp only to be able to run afew times). The golden pug-8man-pre-ToA-days are loong gone.....

the thing that makes daoc 1v1 8v8 and smallman rvr interesting is the fact that it is not arena based! its interesting because you can meet different opponents at different locations in very different inc situations.
if i wanted arena fights i would go to wow or guild wars.

actually i dont know any set grp thats plays together for 10 years.... its changing constantly and also sometimes you have to take a random with you, so the "knowledge" is spreading. still there are many ppl that refuse to get any better but simply always state that the "elitists" need to get off their high horse...
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:50 AM by gotwqqd
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 7:16 AM
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:39 AM
inoeth wrote:
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM
lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Wow
Your self centered mentality is mind boggling.

My bet... if the developers were able to somehow stop this practice they would. It’s just not possible. If we asked the game’s creator I’d bet he said your pathetic practice is against the spirit of the game.

"The spirit of the game". Good stuff you smoking.
A server with 4 hours swap and a custom /gvg toggle command...what you talking about. Devs here have done great things to incentivate both zerg and solo, small, 8v8.
They changed that for all the whiners...and btw it has nothing to do with if your a dick to realmmates.
And FYI , I was talking about the games creator
Not these guys who wanted to deliver a free game from one of its best times
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:52 AM by gotwqqd
inoeth wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 7:23 AM
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:39 AM
inoeth wrote:
Thu 30 Jan 2020 5:06 PM
lol
be a dick, add fights, getting killed, be mad

if you have the freedom to add fights, ppl also have the freedom to not help greefing players!
Wow
Your self centered mentality is mind boggling.

My bet... if the developers were able to somehow stop this practice they would. It’s just not possible. If we asked the game’s creator I’d bet he said your pathetic practice is against the spirit of the game.

you seem to forget that the toons you are playing with and against are actually people. people play this game to have fun and for some players like me 1v1 and 8v8 is fun. then there are people like you who want to destroy our fun. do you think we put up with it? no! we destroy your fun, till you learn to let us play like we want it. why dont you guys not just go to the zerg zones and let us be?
my bet you are the ones who got bullied in school and now want to give it back somehow.... i have zero sympathy for that behavior.

live and let live
Haha you support everything I’ve said
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:57 AM by bigne88
From now on I'm a honor 8v8 clean fight roleplayer. Great call, never tought about this. In the end it is pretty much the truth.
Fri 31 Jan 2020 12:44 PM by inoeth
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 8:57 AM
From now on I'm a honor 8v8 clean fight roleplayer. Great call, never tought about this. In the end it is pretty much the truth.

not sure if trolling anyway i give you a thumbs up for that
Fri 31 Jan 2020 1:04 PM by bigne88
Ill try to sum it up:
Devs has done a great job to make custom changes and make everyone happy, starting from rvr tasks, feathers and claws, teleport chain for the zergers/keeptakers ending with /gvg toggle, maze and ev teleports for 8v8 and small.

We all should be happy with all we got, since there is everything to choose for everyone.

People adds and people pulls out? All good, everything is allowed, lets adapt more and stop complain. There will be always someone enjoying the game differently from ourself, lets deal with that.
For istance I would remove stealthers completly from the server and ghetto them into a stealther's only server...but this cant be done and I will deal with it
Fri 31 Jan 2020 1:30 PM by Cadebrennus
If you guys are such 8v8 badasses then you should NEVER hit anything less than 8 people, EVER. Period. Full stop.
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:01 PM by bigne88
Cadebrennus wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 1:30 PM
If you guys are such 8v8 badasses then you should NEVER hit anything less than 8 people, EVER. Period. Full stop.

How so? Where is written?
And do you think it happens differently always? For istance yesterday night I played 2 hours. I made like 5k RPs because I only fought 8men which mostly pownd me. We killed a couple of soloers who wanted to suicide to get the rvr task done.
Fri 31 Jan 2020 10:59 PM by gotwqqd
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:01 PM
Cadebrennus wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 1:30 PM
If you guys are such 8v8 badasses then you should NEVER hit anything less than 8 people, EVER. Period. Full stop.

How so? Where is written?
And do you think it happens differently always? For istance yesterday night I played 2 hours. I made like 5k RPs because I only fought 8men which mostly pownd me. We killed a couple of soloers who wanted to suicide to get the rvr task done.
I’m sure they chose to attack your eight man instead of possibly killing the multitude of soloers around any defense keep, possibly getting a kill in process
Sat 1 Feb 2020 3:33 AM by bigne88
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 10:59 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 2:01 PM
Cadebrennus wrote:
Fri 31 Jan 2020 1:30 PM
If you guys are such 8v8 badasses then you should NEVER hit anything less than 8 people, EVER. Period. Full stop.

How so? Where is written?
And do you think it happens differently always? For istance yesterday night I played 2 hours. I made like 5k RPs because I only fought 8men which mostly pownd me. We killed a couple of soloers who wanted to suicide to get the rvr task done.
I’m sure they chose to attack your eight man instead of possibly killing the multitude of soloers around any defense keep, possibly getting a kill in process

Dude, you have no idea of what you talking about. Most of the fights happned at the maze (pretty sure you have no idea what is it) and two happned alone the river betweenjamtland and odin
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:11 PM by ZioRed
...and not to mention when groups from different realms defend each other to wipe the third enemy and then go in the opposite direction without fighting their friends, which in my opinion is at very limit of cross-realming. And this happens often to my guild, luckily we're old enough in age to not ragequitting and I'm going to notify this weird behaviour here not to whine or complain but only because someone else started this topic

For example the following screenshots (that I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights), where we were fighting 2 fga (one done in the water and one remained alive in these screeshots) and were added by 1&half fgh which wiped our 1&half group and at the end both the albs and hibs didn't fight each other but retreated in opposite directions even if hibs were in more numbers (I didn't release because I thought the fight between them could have been interesting to follow [yes interesting because I'm totally against 8v8 fights in a massive RvR game], but...). This is constantly happening to us in the last weeks and I'm pretty sure those groups were coordinating together on discord or were "friendly each other", which is really dumb and contrary to any RvRvR game (alliance or friendship between two realms or groups from two realms shouldn't be tolerated in any way and any situation, it was very clear that the two groups above didn't fight intentionally and not because of no-RA or something like that since all of us were already wiped by hibs attacking us from behind).

Albs retreating:

-
Hibs retreating:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:30 PM by Lollie
I'm more concerned on why you use those god awful icons?
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:38 PM by ZioRed
Lollie wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:30 PM
I'm more concerned on why you use those god awful icons?

lol I don't like classic UI and love BobsUI and those icons
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:39 PM by Razur Ur
Haha Dark Templer want respect from 8vs8 Enemy Groups? Rly? You and your 1&half Group is not better how some 8vs8 groups with killing or chasing solo´s!!!
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:42 PM by ZioRed
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:39 PM
Haha Dark Templer want respect from 8vs8 Enemy Groups? Rly? You and your 1&half Group is not better how some 8vs8 groups with killing or chasing solo´s!!!

You probably didn't read or want to understand my post's point of view: you'll never see a single post from me or other guildies whining or complaining about adds or similar, we fight only for Midgard not for RPs (if you were ever in Midgard you could have read in /say "no add plz" but it's only our joke against GvG players ), and the "real" Dark Templars fight ONLY for Midgard, no realm switch. We don't need neither want respect from 8v8 children, and usually our target is the enemy BG but we fight every red target whatever number it is because this is RvR and not GvG or 1v1 or whatever childish gameplay you're trying to play. This game and every other RvR(vR) game is created for MASSIVE MULTIPLAYER ONLINE and not for your dumb 1v1/GvG gameplay (when we want to GvG we log in other games specifically created for that gameplay mode)

For example, but it is my only opinion, I really loved few days ago when mid&hib&alb BGs fought against in big numbers, it doesn't matter who won the fights but partecipating in very big battles was fantastic. I love large BGs' fights.

That said... UP MIDGARD, WAKE UP, WE HAVE TO CATCH THE TRAITORS (any reference to Giosakis is intended)!
Thu 6 Feb 2020 2:51 PM by Razur Ur
ZioRed wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:42 PM
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:39 PM
Haha Dark Templer want respect from 8vs8 Enemy Groups? Rly? You and your 1&half Group is not better how some 8vs8 groups with killing or chasing solo´s!!!

You probably didn't read or want to understand my post's point of view: you'll never see a single post from me or other guildies whining or complaining about adds or similar, we fight only for Midgard not for RPs (if you were ever in Midgard you could have read in /say "no add plz" but it's only our joke against GvG players ), and the "real" Dark Templars fight ONLY for Midgard, no realm switch. We don't need neither want respect from 8v8 children, and usually our target is the enemy BG but we fight every red target whatever number it is because this is RvR and not GvG or 1v1 or whatever childish gameplay you're trying to play. This game and every other RvR(vR) game is created for MASSIVE MULTIPLAYER ONLINE and not for your dumb 1v1/GvG gameplay (when we want to GvG we log in other games specifically created for that gameplay mode)

For example, but it is my only opinion, I really loved few days ago when mid&hib&alb BGs fought against in big numbers, it doesn't matter who won the fights but partecipating in very big battles was fantastic. I love large BGs' fights.

That said... UP MIDGARD, WAKE UP, WE HAVE TO CATCH THE TRAITORS (any reference to Giosakis is intended)!

Why is 1vs1 childish gameplay? i prefer 8vs8 group roaming or if i dont find a group then i playing 1vs1 for more fun. i cannot playing bg zerg everyday with a
tank ( iam a tank player prefer champion) because this is brainless stick up the most time on zerg rvr and i ask me if you want playing for your realm why
your Dark Templer raiding not a tower? No you prefer to chasing smallgroups and solo´s and this is a shitty brainless gameplay!!! And that is the reason
where you shouldn't be surprised if 8vs8 groups only fighting vs your 1&half group and after the fight they stopped fight and runaway ;-).
Thu 6 Feb 2020 3:01 PM by ZioRed
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 2:51 PM
Why is 1vs1 childish gameplay? i prefer 8vs8 group roaming or if i dont find a group then i playing 1vs1 for more fun. i cannot playing bg zerg everyday with a
tank ( iam a tank player prefer champion) because this is brainless stick up the most time on zerg rvr and i ask me if you want playing for your realm why
your Dark Templer raiding not a tower? No you prefer to chasing smallgroups and solo´s and this is a shitty brainless gameplay!!! And that is the reason
where you shouldn't be surprised if 8vs8 groups only fighting vs your 1&half group and after the fight they stopped fight and runaway ;-).

This is only your own (and every other 1v1/smallmen/GvG) idea of what a RvR should be. If it was for your idea then there shouldn't exist any RvR game, that is why I find "childish" any fight that you consider "fair". RvR is not fair, WAR is not fair and that's why I PERSONALLY think that a RvR game cannot be fair as well (it doesn't mean that I'm right, I'm only expressing my own opinion of what a RvR should be). This is also why I continue (and will continue) to play this game and game like this, else I'd have quitted and never downloaded any RvR game.

Or do you really think that a game like DAoC (or any other similar) would have been last for so many years because of 1v1 or GvG? Nevermind, DAoC still exist and is enjoyable because people like Giosakis, Pilzpower, Harder and Oadin continues to create & run in BGs! If it was only made by 1v1 & GvG then DAoC would have been dead by very many years, trust me, I've been programmer and GM in very many unofficial shards so I really know what I'm talking about.

PS: we take towers if we think that it can be a bait for enemies, wait outside or inside and then finally get them, if it's part of a major tactic, as any other "thinking" battle group. While you're only thinking to your GvG fights, as said our main target as DT guild is to defend our realm or attack others (of course as said we also fight soloers or smallmen because we're concentrated on REALM, RPs are secondary target).
Thu 6 Feb 2020 6:36 PM by bigne88
DT complaining about getting zerged by a combined force of alb and hib makes me smile quite a bit.
You just zerg people down 24/7, you are getting paied with the same coin and no respect.
Thu 6 Feb 2020 7:16 PM by inoeth
ZioRed wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 3:01 PM
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 2:51 PM
Why is 1vs1 childish gameplay? i prefer 8vs8 group roaming or if i dont find a group then i playing 1vs1 for more fun. i cannot playing bg zerg everyday with a
tank ( iam a tank player prefer champion) because this is brainless stick up the most time on zerg rvr and i ask me if you want playing for your realm why
your Dark Templer raiding not a tower? No you prefer to chasing smallgroups and solo´s and this is a shitty brainless gameplay!!! And that is the reason
where you shouldn't be surprised if 8vs8 groups only fighting vs your 1&half group and after the fight they stopped fight and runaway ;-).

This is only your own (and every other 1v1/smallmen/GvG) idea of what a RvR should be. If it was for your idea then there shouldn't exist any RvR game, that is why I find "childish" any fight that you consider "fair". RvR is not fair, WAR is not fair and that's why I PERSONALLY think that a RvR game cannot be fair as well (it doesn't mean that I'm right, I'm only expressing my own opinion of what a RvR should be). This is also why I continue (and will continue) to play this game and game like this, else I'd have quitted and never downloaded any RvR game.

Or do you really think that a game like DAoC (or any other similar) would have been last for so many years because of 1v1 or GvG? Nevermind, DAoC still exist and is enjoyable because people like Giosakis, Pilzpower, Harder and Oadin continues to create & run in BGs! If it was only made by 1v1 & GvG then DAoC would have been dead by very many years, trust me, I've been programmer and GM in very many unofficial shards so I really know what I'm talking about.

PS: we take towers if we think that it can be a bait for enemies, wait outside or inside and then finally get them, if it's part of a major tactic, as any other "thinking" battle group. While you're only thinking to your GvG fights, as said our main target as DT guild is to defend our realm or attack others (of course as said we also fight soloers or smallmen because we're concentrated on REALM, RPs are secondary target).

ppl like you are the reason so many left the server because its just zerg everywhere. btw this is not war this is a game and the only childish person here is you stating the opposite. zerging every solo/small/8 is like stealin lollipops from children, with 10 ppl. thats such a lame play style and you in addition seem to be proud of that. did you get bullied in school and need to take vengeance now? what is wrong with you? also this "realm" mentality is so stupid, most of the daoc players have played every realm in the last 20 years and dont give a shit about "realm pride" you must be new to the game to still have that [edited by cooky] behavior, or just really really stupid. can you just leave plz? we dont need this behavior in this establishment.
Thu 6 Feb 2020 7:49 PM by ZioRed
My dear children, you all have your own idea about what RvR means, we still have our own. You call Zerg what the goal of a massive multiplayer is, we play a RvR game exactly the way a massive multiplayer is created for, no way our ideas will ever meet. Go play CounterStrike if you're looking for GvG, but RvR and MMO games are something totally different from what you're trying to play, and I personally don't really care much about who leaves or remains
Thu 6 Feb 2020 8:06 PM by ZioRed
inoeth wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 7:16 PM
also this "realm" mentality is so stupid, most of the daoc players have played every realm in the last 20 years and dont give a shit about "realm pride" you must be new to the game to still have that [Edited by Cooky] behavior, or just really really stupid. can you just leave plz? we dont need this behavior in this establishment.

Yes I'm "proud" of my realm pride, even after 15 years as DAoC player and 10 years as DAoC server programmer, even if I was never "bullied at school" (you're very very rude to say something stupid like that, really really dumb, shame on you!). It's something you dudes lost many time ago, it seems. And my political attitude is definitely not something that should be of any interest to you.
Thu 6 Feb 2020 9:14 PM by Cooky
Guys, please calm down a bit or we will close this thread.
Fri 7 Feb 2020 4:59 AM by gotwqqd
Gotta love the “its not war it’s a game “ argument

So weak
Fri 7 Feb 2020 6:04 AM by Cadebrennus
ZioRed wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:11 PM
...and not to mention when groups from different realms defend each other to wipe the third enemy and then go in the opposite direction without fighting their friends, which in my opinion is at very limit of cross-realming. And this happens often to my guild, luckily we're old enough in age to not ragequitting and I'm going to notify this weird behaviour here not to whine or complain but only because someone else started this topic

For example the following screenshots (that I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights), where we were fighting 2 fga (one done in the water and one remained alive in these screeshots) and were added by 1&half fgh which wiped our 1&half group and at the end both the albs and hibs didn't fight each other but retreated in opposite directions even if hibs were in more numbers (I didn't release because I thought the fight between them could have been interesting to follow [yes interesting because I'm totally against 8v8 fights in a massive RvR game], but...). This is constantly happening to us in the last weeks and I'm pretty sure those groups were coordinating together on discord or were "friendly each other", which is really dumb and contrary to any RvRvR game (alliance or friendship between two realms or groups from two realms shouldn't be tolerated in any way and any situation, it was very clear that the two groups above didn't fight intentionally and not because of no-RA or something like that since all of us were already wiped by hibs attacking us from behind).

Albs retreating:

-
Hibs retreating:


I'd say that this is less crossrealming and traitorous (as in allowing your realm mates to die) and more of a mutual hate for a third realm. I'm not sure what time or day and time zone this happened but sometimes when a particular realm just absolutely dominates the frontier in numbers (like Mid often does) the other two realms are more interested in fighting that realm than each other.
Fri 7 Feb 2020 1:33 PM by bigne88
Guys, just chill and dont take this game too seriously. Live and let live. People plays differently from you? They dont go against server rules? Fine, deal with it. And dont worry, for my personal experience, admins are really looking into this things when reported.
My party and a mid party where investigated by an admin really quickly, when during an 8v8 between this 2 groups, we got engaged by an overwhelming Albion zerg and we instinctively turned against them.
Albs reported this to admins and in 5 minutes a gm showed up to investigate if we did that choordinated on porpouse.
The admin heard the version of both groups and since there was no premeditation we just got warned that if there was any suspicious of crossrealming, we could be banned.

Tldr; the enemy of my enemy can be my friend. Turning against an overwhelming force is ok and even reasonable. Organizing a ctossrealm BG is not and dosent make sense (never heard of nonesense like this).
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:17 PM by ZioRed
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 1:33 PM
Guys, just chill and dont take this game too seriously.

Of course, my dear. My seriousness is limited to the game (any game where the player chooses a faction) and ONLY in game, I don't insult RL things don't call "nazi", "brainless", "bullied at school" (when I said "children/childish" was related to continuously yelling those kind of insults from people only because the others don't play like them).

I love to play as RPG (my first ever and loved MMORPG was "The 4th Calling" just before DAoC was released, if anyone here knows it was very fun on strict-RPG ruleset) and so I emphatize the RPG part of ANY game (heal/buff/support everybody when playing healer toons, defend/help my faction's fellows when they're in difficult situations, etc), no matter if the game is new or old, or if the others don't like that because for them it's only a "game around numbers" (RR, RPs, BPs or whatever else). Maybe it's too difficult to understand for people who only care about personal toon progression (or personal challenge).

That is why I've still a "realm pride" even on a 20 years old game (PS: "this is not war but a game" is nonsense, this is a war game between 3 realms and as said I'm a RPG player so I act accordingly and not because "I'm stupid", I'm trying to explain THIS point of view many times, though the guys here continue to insult like that. It's not that I get an axe and decapitate you if I see you in RL because you play hib/alb, that part is only when I play and any appellative for me is only for in-game realm toons and not directed to the RL person <3

That being said, see you in frontier my dear adversary!

PS: as I said in my first post in this thread, I didn't write that to report the people in those screenshots (else I'd have done the same day I took the screens and in my own topic), but more to add my2cents to this thread without any third-subtle-reason (note the phrase "I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights", not to report them which in fact I didn't make).
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:56 PM by bigne88
ZioRed wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:17 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 1:33 PM
Guys, just chill and dont take this game too seriously.

Of course, my dear. My seriousness is limited to the game (any game where the player chooses a faction) and ONLY in game, I don't insult RL things don't call "nazi", "brainless", "bullied at school" (when I said "children/childish" was related to continuously yelling those kind of insults from people only because the others don't play like them).

I love to play as RPG (my first ever and loved MMORPG was "The 4th Calling" just before DAoC was released, if anyone here knows it was very fun on strict-RPG ruleset) and so I emphatize the RPG part of ANY game (heal/buff/support everybody when playing healer toons, defend/help my faction's fellows when they're in difficult situations, etc), no matter if the game is new or old, or if the others don't like that because for them it's only a "game around numbers" (RR, RPs, BPs or whatever else). Maybe it's too difficult to understand for people who only care about personal toon progression (or personal challenge).

That is why I've still a "realm pride" even on a 20 years old game (PS: "this is not war but a game" is nonsense, this is a war game between 3 realms and as said I'm a RPG player so I act accordingly and not because "I'm stupid", I'm trying to explain THIS point of view many times, though the guys here continue to insult like that. It's not that I get an axe and decapitate you if I see you in RL because you play hib/alb, that part is only when I play and any appellative for me is only for in-game realm toons and not directed to the RL person <3

That being said, see you in frontier my dear adversary!

PS: as I said in my first post in this thread, I didn't write that to report the people in those screenshots (else I'd have done the same day I took the screens and in my own topic), but more to add my2cents to this thread without any third-subtle-reason (note the phrase "I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights", not to report them which in fact I didn't make).

This is your point of you; it is reasonable and I respect it. Tough, I'm 100% not agree with it.
So what? Nothing, who cares, we both are wrong or right, it is subjective. Both mentalities are needed to keep server population hig.

The only objective things are server rules and if some behaviours are against it, gms are there for a reason. Anything else is pure trashtalk, good only to entertain some drama-lovers.
Sat 8 Feb 2020 5:52 PM by inoeth
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:56 PM
ZioRed wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:17 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 1:33 PM
Guys, just chill and dont take this game too seriously.

Of course, my dear. My seriousness is limited to the game (any game where the player chooses a faction) and ONLY in game, I don't insult RL things don't call "nazi", "brainless", "bullied at school" (when I said "children/childish" was related to continuously yelling those kind of insults from people only because the others don't play like them).

I love to play as RPG (my first ever and loved MMORPG was "The 4th Calling" just before DAoC was released, if anyone here knows it was very fun on strict-RPG ruleset) and so I emphatize the RPG part of ANY game (heal/buff/support everybody when playing healer toons, defend/help my faction's fellows when they're in difficult situations, etc), no matter if the game is new or old, or if the others don't like that because for them it's only a "game around numbers" (RR, RPs, BPs or whatever else). Maybe it's too difficult to understand for people who only care about personal toon progression (or personal challenge).

That is why I've still a "realm pride" even on a 20 years old game (PS: "this is not war but a game" is nonsense, this is a war game between 3 realms and as said I'm a RPG player so I act accordingly and not because "I'm stupid", I'm trying to explain THIS point of view many times, though the guys here continue to insult like that. It's not that I get an axe and decapitate you if I see you in RL because you play hib/alb, that part is only when I play and any appellative for me is only for in-game realm toons and not directed to the RL person <3

That being said, see you in frontier my dear adversary!

PS: as I said in my first post in this thread, I didn't write that to report the people in those screenshots (else I'd have done the same day I took the screens and in my own topic), but more to add my2cents to this thread without any third-subtle-reason (note the phrase "I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights", not to report them which in fact I didn't make).

This is your point of you; it is reasonable and I respect it. Tough, I'm 100% not agree with it.
So what? Nothing, who cares, we both are wrong or right, it is subjective. Both mentalities are needed to keep server population hig.

The only objective things are server rules and if some behaviours are against it, gms are there for a reason. Anything else is pure trashtalk, good only to entertain some drama-lovers.

thing is, we respect that some want to zerg, but i dont feel any respect for our playstyle from the zergers... why dont they just go play vs other zergers and let us play how we feel is right? i tell you, they are of the kind "its not enough that i win, others must lose" some guys just want to see the world burning
Sat 8 Feb 2020 6:03 PM by bigne88
inoeth wrote:
Sat 8 Feb 2020 5:52 PM
bigne88 wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:56 PM
ZioRed wrote:
Fri 7 Feb 2020 2:17 PM
Of course, my dear. My seriousness is limited to the game (any game where the player chooses a faction) and ONLY in game, I don't insult RL things don't call "nazi", "brainless", "bullied at school" (when I said "children/childish" was related to continuously yelling those kind of insults from people only because the others don't play like them).

I love to play as RPG (my first ever and loved MMORPG was "The 4th Calling" just before DAoC was released, if anyone here knows it was very fun on strict-RPG ruleset) and so I emphatize the RPG part of ANY game (heal/buff/support everybody when playing healer toons, defend/help my faction's fellows when they're in difficult situations, etc), no matter if the game is new or old, or if the others don't like that because for them it's only a "game around numbers" (RR, RPs, BPs or whatever else). Maybe it's too difficult to understand for people who only care about personal toon progression (or personal challenge).

That is why I've still a "realm pride" even on a 20 years old game (PS: "this is not war but a game" is nonsense, this is a war game between 3 realms and as said I'm a RPG player so I act accordingly and not because "I'm stupid", I'm trying to explain THIS point of view many times, though the guys here continue to insult like that. It's not that I get an axe and decapitate you if I see you in RL because you play hib/alb, that part is only when I play and any appellative for me is only for in-game realm toons and not directed to the RL person <3

That being said, see you in frontier my dear adversary!

PS: as I said in my first post in this thread, I didn't write that to report the people in those screenshots (else I'd have done the same day I took the screens and in my own topic), but more to add my2cents to this thread without any third-subtle-reason (note the phrase "I took for ourselves to identify the people and address them in later fights", not to report them which in fact I didn't make).

This is your point of you; it is reasonable and I respect it. Tough, I'm 100% not agree with it.
So what? Nothing, who cares, we both are wrong or right, it is subjective. Both mentalities are needed to keep server population hig.

The only objective things are server rules and if some behaviours are against it, gms are there for a reason. Anything else is pure trashtalk, good only to entertain some drama-lovers.

thing is, we respect that some want to zerg, but i dont feel any respect for our playstyle from the zergers... why dont they just go play vs other zergers and let us play how we feel is right? i tell you, they are of the kind "its not enough that i win, others must lose" some guys just want to see the world burning

You cant pretend that everyone is enlighted with our good ethic and education. If they feel like bragging about cleanfight...let them roar, who cares.
Sat 8 Feb 2020 6:52 PM by Quik
So let me get this straight...

People are playing in a REALM VS REALM game and they are upset people from other realms are attacking them in an RvR area just because they are already engaged in a fight? So basically DAoC is no longer an RvR game to these people? They have the right to ask everyone else to stop playing how the game was designed just so they can have a clean fight? That the jist? I'm really lost...
Sat 8 Feb 2020 9:50 PM by gotwqqd
Quik wrote:
Sat 8 Feb 2020 6:52 PM
So let me get this straight...

People are playing in a REALM VS REALM game and they are upset people from other realms are attacking them in an RvR area just because they are already engaged in a fight? So basically DAoC is no longer an RvR game to these people? They have the right to ask everyone else to stop playing how the game was designed just so they can have a clean fight? That the jist? I'm really lost...
Not only that, the vast majority of these players are the biggest hypocrites about adding or simply mowing down solo players
Mon 10 Feb 2020 7:08 AM by Sepplord
I doubt that the average respect of the playstyle zerging is bigger than the general respect of the playstyle 8vs8.
Mon 10 Feb 2020 9:46 AM by Razur Ur
Yesterday the Noob Templer roaming with two 2 groups beetwen Bled Coast and Nottmor Coast for 2 hours and farming only Solo´s and Smallgroups and this is
nice Realm Defense? go and raid anywhere enemy Towers but do it not so a shit!!!
Mon 10 Feb 2020 10:42 AM by Forlornhope
Razur Ur wrote:
Mon 10 Feb 2020 9:46 AM
Yesterday the Noob Templer roaming with two 2 groups beetwen Bled Coast and Nottmor Coast for 2 hours and farming only Solo´s and Smallgroups and this is
nice Realm Defense? go and raid anywhere enemy Towers but do it not so a shit!!!

Didn't you know? This server's just a rp farm simulator and nothing else matters.
Sun 29 Mar 2020 2:18 PM by Tsol
ZioRed wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:42 PM
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:39 PM
Haha Dark Templer want respect from 8vs8 Enemy Groups? Rly? You and your 1&half Group is not better how some 8vs8 groups with killing or chasing solo´s!!!



For example, but it is my only opinion, I really loved few days ago when mid&hib&alb BGs fought against in big numbers, it doesn't matter who won the fights but partecipating in very big battles was fantastic. I love large BGs' fights.

That said... UP MIDGARD, WAKE UP, WE HAVE TO CATCH THE TRAITORS (any reference to Giosakis is intended)!

Calling someone a "traitor" when you and your whole guild combined haven't taken the number of relics + keeps/towers for Midgard he has taken and the amount of effort he has made to help Midgard dominate- I suggest you and a lot more Mids start to rethink the word Traitor. Plus by going to Alb he helped you enjoy once more all these mega BG battles between all 3 realms which didn't exist for like 2+ months from November and after....

Meanwhile take a good look at Midgard atm where for some reason there is No BG atm for like 1month and ask yourself why? Its easy to blame a traitor, while i suggest you and everybody else that likes to use the word traitor, to take a good look into the mirror and ask yourself why Midgard Eu time BG suxx so bad?!
Sun 29 Mar 2020 2:52 PM by ZioRed
@Tsol lol I used "traitor" only as a "joke" and pretty "roleplaying" word (I like Giosakis as he runs BGs for his realm[s]), it definitely wasn't meant to be a RL offense, I never offend RL nobody be it friend or adversary. My words are EVER as roleplaying, you probably missed the thing that I say in every post of mine: I'm a ROLEplayer and not a FARMplayer, you'll notice it also when and how I speak in game (in a sort of medieval language, except for Discord or in guild chat). I know that some/most of you could not be involved in any roleplaying style, but I love roleplaying.

By the way, I'm having a break from game since 2 or 3 weeks, so I cannot defend or attack anything (and for sure I couldn't take or defend any relic alone and unfortunately I'm not a good tactician to run as BG leader).
Mon 30 Mar 2020 6:19 PM by Durzo
Tsol wrote:
Sun 29 Mar 2020 2:18 PM
ZioRed wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:42 PM
Razur Ur wrote:
Thu 6 Feb 2020 12:39 PM
Haha Dark Templer want respect from 8vs8 Enemy Groups? Rly? You and your 1&half Group is not better how some 8vs8 groups with killing or chasing solo´s!!!



For example, but it is my only opinion, I really loved few days ago when mid&hib&alb BGs fought against in big numbers, it doesn't matter who won the fights but partecipating in very big battles was fantastic. I love large BGs' fights.

That said... UP MIDGARD, WAKE UP, WE HAVE TO CATCH THE TRAITORS (any reference to Giosakis is intended)!

Calling someone a "traitor" when you and your whole guild combined haven't taken the number of relics + keeps/towers for Midgard he has taken and the amount of effort he has made to help Midgard dominate- I suggest you and a lot more Mids start to rethink the word Traitor. Plus by going to Alb he helped you enjoy once more all these mega BG battles between all 3 realms which didn't exist for like 2+ months from November and after....

Meanwhile take a good look at Midgard atm where for some reason there is No BG atm for like 1month and ask yourself why? Its easy to blame a traitor, while i suggest you and everybody else that likes to use the word traitor, to take a good look into the mirror and ask yourself why Midgard Eu time BG suxx so bad?!
you are giosakis though... you’re talking awfully good about yourself while making it sound like it’s not you lol
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:50 AM by Centenario
Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:11 AM by Blitze
I think i may have fallen victim to this last night. And it sounds even more sinister than i originally thought... [I can't believe people would stoop to this low level. i mean you arn't even participating in the game anymore.]

Anyway here is what happened to me:
On my solo friar I came out of the center tunnel in EV and saw (with a restricted view) a couple of Albs (inc. Nefcaiti) and Mids "engaged". So... i did what any "loyal" Alb would do, ran to the aid of my realm-mates and attacked the first Norse I came upon. I saw that this was a group Vs group fight and unsurprisingly I immediately became the target for the midgard /assist train. Never fear though, whilst i was being killed I valiantly called down a static tempest and prayed that my graceful dexterity would give my fellow Albs a good chance to fight back and win: For King and Country! . However. I noticed that the Albs were not doing any damage to the Mids (& vice-versa) and once i was slain, both groups just slowly and gently spread away from each other.
Finally, The so-called "Albion" group didn't rezz their fallen comrade [me] or communicate about whatever cross-realm strategy they were doing.
It all reeks like Inconnu feet.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:26 AM by inoeth
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:11 AM
I think i may have fallen victim to this last night. And it sounds even more sinister than i originally thought... [I can't believe people would stoop to this low level. i mean you arn't even participating in the game anymore.]

Anyway here is what happened to me:
On my solo friar I came out of the center tunnel in EV and saw (with a restricted view) a couple of Albs (inc. Nefcaiti) and Mids "engaged". So... i did what any "loyal" Alb would do, ran to the aid of my realm-mates and attacked the first Norse I came upon. I saw that this was a group Vs group fight and unsurprisingly I immediately became the target for the midgard /assist train. Never fear though, whilst i was being killed I valiantly called down a static tempest and prayed that my graceful dexterity would give my fellow Albs a good chance to fight back and win: For King and Country! . However. I noticed that the Albs were not doing any damage to the Mids (& vice-versa) and once i was slain, both groups just slowly and gently spread away from each other.
Finally, The so-called "Albion" group didn't rezz their fallen comrade [me] or communicate about whatever cross-realm strategy they were doing.
It all reeks like Inconnu feet.

well deserved.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:11 AM by Fk_
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:50 AM
Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

Name the groups doing this. I seriously doubt the veracity of this claim LUL.
People are "pseudo fighting", giving themselves a 1mn immunity? Calling you a liar and a paranoid here.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:18 AM by Blitze
Horg; you would say that you dirty dirty Middie!
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:28 AM by rafjord
love the salty tears of people adding my 8v8 fights and getting killed then QQing on forum. Its awesome. it fuels me. I cant wait to do it again today.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:40 AM by Onnit
You don’t see random schmucks jumping into a McGregor or Tyson Fury fight, people respect the spectacle and just observe, have some decency to do the same rather than ruining fair fights for a few rps like the leeching monkeys that most of you on the forums are.

Chat shi* get banged.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:41 AM by Blitze
rafjord wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:28 AM
love the salty tears of people adding my 8v8 fights and getting killed then QQing on forum. Its awesome. it fuels me. I cant wait to do it again today.

I hope that’s a joke. However, If in all seriousness you do get enjoyment out of other people’s misery, then you should probably get counselling or at least talk to a mental health professional.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 12:18 PM by MrWolf
8v8 elitists are all just like scientology members dutchruddering themselves.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 12:25 PM by thirian24
Onnit wrote: You don’t see random schmucks jumping into a McGregor or Tyson Fury fight, people respect the spectacle and just observe, have some decency to do the same rather than ruining fair fights for a few rps like the leeching monkeys that most of you on the forums are.

Chat shi* get banged.
rafjord wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:28 AM
love the salty tears of people adding my 8v8 fights and getting killed then QQing on forum. Its awesome. it fuels me. I cant wait to do it again today.

This is the kind of attitude that Phoenix staff thought deserved a special RP bonus.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 12:49 PM by inoeth
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:41 AM
rafjord wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:28 AM
love the salty tears of people adding my 8v8 fights and getting killed then QQing on forum. Its awesome. it fuels me. I cant wait to do it again today.

I hope that’s a joke. However, If in all seriousness you do get enjoyment out of other people’s misery, then you should probably get counselling or at least talk to a mental health professional.

says the adder that ruins enjoyment out of pure enjoyment.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 1:33 PM by Centenario
Fk_ wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 11:11 AM
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:50 AM
Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

Name the groups doing this. I seriously doubt the veracity of this claim LUL.
People are "pseudo fighting", giving themselves a 1mn immunity? Calling you a liar and a paranoid here.

I don't know their name or guildname, just people in EV were doing this all EU night yesterday.
Don't want to know their name or guildname either. Never will.
I just know they are doing bannable offense described above. Farming RP from adders and disguising it as 8v8.
They might occasionally kill each other, but most of what they do is what I described.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 1:56 PM by rafjord
why would these groups needs immunity to win fights lol.
be honest with yourself, if you think your losing fights vs good groups because of immunities then your straight up delusional.
the 8v8 groups are a community. they play all 3 realms, and group often with eachother on multiple realms. we care about a fair fight requiring SKILL not numbers.
when notorious baddies like DT for example, add fights, your ruining a test of skill between 16 people that know eachother.
this will never change. its how we play the game. we don't care about realm pride. we don't care about other realm mates. we care about bragging rights over the other 8v8 people that we laugh/troll/group/play with week in week out.
add our fights and we will continue to pull off and allow you to die.
don't like it? then run round the fight and avoid it
Thu 2 Apr 2020 1:59 PM by inoeth
i highly doubt that this is done on a regular basis and on purpose.
if thats really happening, i suggest you to record some evidence.

my experiance is that there are happening many strange things in daoc just like grps suddenly turn and run directly through you as a stealther on open field, some say its radar but imo those things just happen randomly. same with your described practice, imo that sounds like there was a 8v8 and someone added, one grp pulled off and the other handled the adders. ofc they may had some immunities at that point.

my advice: dont add, than you dont get fucked up by these guys.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:05 PM by Blitze
I assume you never chase down and roll over visi-solos... as that is completely against your “only fair-fight gameplay”

I’ll be a happy /waving friar to see you guys just whizz by me! Cos atm I seem to get ploughed down by every mid or hib group.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:07 PM by Centenario
If I run out to them 5 times in a row after fully rebuffing, while they still havent killed each other, and are just disengaging whenever I add.
It means in the end they have killed 8*5=40 adders and they have killed maybe 1 or 2 of their Rrrp-buddies.

Leads me to conclude they are farming RP on adders rather than doing 8v8.

Just test it.

They most of the time have full immunities and are waiting for the first opportunity to switch target/disengage.

It's like big companies saying they don't share your data, they are righteous with data. (8vs8 only doing 8v8)
Then saying only if you agree to share your data they will share it. (But if you add us thats free RP for us)
Then forcing you to agree to share to enjoy most functionality. (There is no way to do 8v8 cause they are constantly being added)
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:11 PM by rafjord
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:07 PM
If I run out to them 5 times in a row after fully rebuffing, while they still havent killed each other, and are just disengaging whenever I add.
It means in the end they have killed 8*5=40 adders and they have killed maybe 1 or 2 of their Rrrp-buddies.

Leads me to conclude they are farming RP on adders rather than doing 8v8.

Just test it.

They most of the time have full immunities and are waiting for the first opportunity to switch target/disengage.

If you have ran into a fight 5 times and died 5 times (highly likely if you belong to Dark Templar) then maybe stop running into the fight LOL. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:34 PM by rafjord
the running down solos smallman thing is really just a flip of a coin. you've got maybe 20 8man groups running at peak time, you cant expect every single one of them to avoid soloers/smallmen. people generally remember being ganked. they tend to forget the times an 8 man passed them.
I also have close to 2000 visible solo kills ON SPEEDLESS CLASSES, so im well aware of your struggle. I don't take to the forums to qq tho. I build an 8 man and go find the people who killed me, or, I avoid them if I can. ez.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:53 PM by Ele
Centenario wrote: Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

The conclusion you get out if this sounds unlikely to me. Most fights start exactly like you describe, groups try to get cc's/rupts etc. out, and depending on the involved groups setups, this can lead to a really long time where "nothing is happening". While this is happening, some kind of adds occur and both 8mans - now with full set of immunities - tend to the adding party.


Centenario wrote: I don't know their name or guildname, just people in EV were doing this all EU night yesterday.
Don't want to know their name or guildname either. Never will.
I just know they are doing bannable offense described above. Farming RP from adders and disguising it as 8v8.
They might occasionally kill each other, but most of what they do is what I described.

My guess is you are simply mixing up different groups disengaging and clearing groups that joined the fight.
This can happen very easily, regarding the number of groups that are out on a regular basis. A Screenshot from Tuesday EU PT:



22 8mans, not counting the ones who run around as 8 but don't use /gvg toggle. Many of them run identical setups, so it is even harder to distinguish them if you do not recognise them by name.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:14 PM by bigne88
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:11 AM
I think i may have fallen victim to this last night. And it sounds even more sinister than i originally thought... [I can't believe people would stoop to this low level. i mean you arn't even participating in the game anymore.]

Anyway here is what happened to me:
On my solo friar I came out of the center tunnel in EV and saw (with a restricted view) a couple of Albs (inc. Nefcaiti) and Mids "engaged". So... i did what any "loyal" Alb would do, ran to the aid of my realm-mates and attacked the first Norse I came upon. I saw that this was a group Vs group fight and unsurprisingly I immediately became the target for the midgard /assist train. Never fear though, whilst i was being killed I valiantly called down a static tempest and prayed that my graceful dexterity would give my fellow Albs a good chance to fight back and win: For King and Country! . However. I noticed that the Albs were not doing any damage to the Mids (& vice-versa) and once i was slain, both groups just slowly and gently spread away from each other.
Finally, The so-called "Albion" group didn't rezz their fallen comrade [me] or communicate about whatever cross-realm strategy they were doing.
It all reeks like Inconnu feet.

you added a fight. you deserve to be eliminated.
Your fellow realm comrades wanted to fight with HONOR, without the help of a random scrub, even if it means to die. They walk trough many battlefields to show everyone that they are the best. Dont put your stinky finger on it. Get some honor for yourself and go fight 1v1.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:27 PM by Kaziera
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:07 PM
If I run out to them 5 times in a row after fully rebuffing, while they still havent killed each other, and are just disengaging whenever I add.
It means in the end they have killed 8*5=40 adders and they have killed maybe 1 or 2 of their Rrrp-buddies.

Leads me to conclude they are farming RP on adders rather than doing 8v8.

Just test it.

They most of the time have full immunities and are waiting for the first opportunity to switch target/disengage.

It's like big companies saying they don't share your data, they are righteous with data. (8vs8 only doing 8v8)
Then saying only if you agree to share your data they will share it. (But if you add us thats free RP for us)
Then forcing you to agree to share to enjoy most functionality. (There is no way to do 8v8 cause they are constantly being added)

Wanns buy s tinfoil hat?

I got all sizes, only 99.99 a piece.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:33 PM by JimD
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:11 AM
I think i may have fallen victim to this last night. And it sounds even more sinister than i originally thought... [I can't believe people would stoop to this low level. i mean you arn't even participating in the game anymore.]

Anyway here is what happened to me:
On my solo friar I came out of the center tunnel in EV and saw (with a restricted view) a couple of Albs (inc. Nefcaiti) and Mids "engaged". So... i did what any "loyal" Alb would do, ran to the aid of my realm-mates and attacked the first Norse I came upon. I saw that this was a group Vs group fight and unsurprisingly I immediately became the target for the midgard /assist train. Never fear though, whilst i was being killed I valiantly called down a static tempest and prayed that my graceful dexterity would give my fellow Albs a good chance to fight back and win: For King and Country! . However. I noticed that the Albs were not doing any damage to the Mids (& vice-versa) and once i was slain, both groups just slowly and gently spread away from each other.
Finally, The so-called "Albion" group didn't rezz their fallen comrade [me] or communicate about whatever cross-realm strategy they were doing.
It all reeks like Inconnu feet.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5EFaI6vxIw

credit: norad
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:37 PM by Centenario
I am just proving, by the absurd, that you 8v8 need an 8v8 arena, or they could get banned for that absurd scenarios of RP farming adders with full immunity.
You cannot prove that you did not communicate with the opposing party and did not organize to do that style of RP farming.
It is clearly visible that one party disengages, and lets the other party attack the adders who are playing RvR style and not 8v8 style, who are at a disadvantage due to immunity(ies).

Either the 8v8 have to avoid adders by going to the edges of the map, or they need to stop disengaging, or they need their own arena.

By continuing this way they are giving a poor view of RvR/server to casuals.
They appear as the opposite of what they are trying to achieve:
Scum instead of Cream
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:51 PM by Ele
Centenario wrote: I am just proving,...
nothing. You are giving a view on an engagement of groups, most likely misjudging what is happening. The scenario I provided earlier is much more likely to have actually happened, because it does not rely on the assumption of two groups agreeing to spam cc's etc. on each other to farm rps on a third realms groups, which would need 16 people to agree etc. I can't imagine this scenario.

Centenario wrote: You cannot prove that you did not communicate with the opposing party...
There is not much need for communicating between 8mans. The only communication that is happening on a regular basis might be a /yell if a group gets/spots adds and tells the other party to pull off/focus the adds instead of them, depending on which realm joins in. All that is needed apart of that has been implemented via the /gvg commands, showing in which zone which group currently is.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:01 PM by Centenario
Ele wrote: You are giving a view on an engagement of groups, most likely misjudging what is happening.
I am just giving facts:
- 8v8 is in an open-RvR area
- is giving immunities to another group
- is communicating with another realm
- is disengaging from a fight to let the other group get free kills on the "adders"
- is doing this scenario multiple times within a short amount of time (anytime adders engage)

In my books that is factual RP farming strategy.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:03 PM by Ferboten
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:50 AM
Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

Hahahaha

Oh you're serious... let me laugh even harder.

Hahahahahahaha
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:06 PM by inoeth
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 2:05 PM
I assume you never chase down and roll over visi-solos... as that is completely against your “only fair-fight gameplay”

I’ll be a happy /waving friar to see you guys just whizz by me! Cos atm I seem to get ploughed down by every mid or hib group.

if you dont add you can be sure that the Error grp will nbot chase you. if you have some reputation, many grps will run by. but yeah even a single add can destroy that...
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:11 PM by inoeth
JimD wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:33 PM
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 10:11 AM
I think i may have fallen victim to this last night. And it sounds even more sinister than i originally thought... [I can't believe people would stoop to this low level. i mean you arn't even participating in the game anymore.]

Anyway here is what happened to me:
On my solo friar I came out of the center tunnel in EV and saw (with a restricted view) a couple of Albs (inc. Nefcaiti) and Mids "engaged". So... i did what any "loyal" Alb would do, ran to the aid of my realm-mates and attacked the first Norse I came upon. I saw that this was a group Vs group fight and unsurprisingly I immediately became the target for the midgard /assist train. Never fear though, whilst i was being killed I valiantly called down a static tempest and prayed that my graceful dexterity would give my fellow Albs a good chance to fight back and win: For King and Country! . However. I noticed that the Albs were not doing any damage to the Mids (& vice-versa) and once i was slain, both groups just slowly and gently spread away from each other.
Finally, The so-called "Albion" group didn't rezz their fallen comrade [me] or communicate about whatever cross-realm strategy they were doing.
It all reeks like Inconnu feet.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5EFaI6vxIw

credit: norad



hahahah im shitting my pants, very nice you got that captured ;D
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:17 PM by Ele
Centenario wrote: I am just giving facts:
- 8v8 is in an open-RvR area
Agreed.

Centenario wrote: - is giving immunities to another group
You can't fight any enemy without handing out immunities, regardless of which XvsX setting we are talking about.

Centenario wrote: - is communicating with another realm
In a certain manner, yes. The same way you would /monty an enemy or /bow after a fight you enjoyed: with a /-command. More is not needed for what you are describing.

Centenario wrote: - is disengaging from a fight to let the other group get free kills on the "adders"
Which is not against any rules.

Centenario wrote: - is doing this scenario multiple times within a short amount of time (anytime adders engage)
If there is a lot of traffic, sure. In phoenix vids are lots of videos that show how an 8vs8 turns into an addgroup-slaughterhouse. First one that comes to my mind:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=neshK9hvfKs

Centenario wrote: In my books that is factual RP farming strategy.
Guess in your book 3+3=9 then. There is no strategy, just the idea of - lets take the numbers from tuesday - 136 players that think 8vs8, not 8vs9 or something else, is a desirable form of rvr.
Edit: Typo.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:00 PM by rafjord
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 3:37 PM
I am just proving, by the absurd, that you 8v8 need an 8v8 arena, or they could get banned for that absurd scenarios of RP farming adders with full immunity.
You cannot prove that you did not communicate with the opposing party and did not organize to do that style of RP farming.
It is clearly visible that one party disengages, and lets the other party attack the adders who are playing RvR style and not 8v8 style, who are at a disadvantage due to immunity(ies).

Either the 8v8 have to avoid adders by going to the edges of the map, or they need to stop disengaging, or they need their own arena.

By continuing this way they are giving a poor view of RvR/server to casuals.
They appear as the opposite of what they are trying to achieve:
Scum instead of Cream

Your at a disadvantage cos your bad players. Bad playstyle, zero skill. STart running 8v8 , even if you get farmed, over time you will get the respect from 8 man players.
Don't come and play with the big boys if u don't like dying
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:02 PM by Teisiphone
Truth is, the killing of morons who comedically fly into your fights by mutual consent of both groups is one of the sweetest aspects in the game. Even more so if they rage and launch threats at you right after. I for one don't even care about your RPs.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:02 PM by bigne88
Centenario wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 4:01 PM
Ele wrote: You are giving a view on an engagement of groups, most likely misjudging what is happening.
I am just giving facts:
- 8v8 is in an open-RvR area
- is giving immunities to another group
- is communicating with another realm
- is disengaging from a fight to let the other group get free kills on the "adders"
- is doing this scenario multiple times within a short amount of time (anytime adders engage)

In my books that is factual RP farming strategy.

your plot twisting attempt is pretty miserable.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:08 PM by Blitze
Nice vid capture... I really did come out of that tunnel at the wrong time! I was excited to be part of a little skirmish with a Norse savage... Sadly I brought my shaft to the wrong sort of shaft-fight... It was a shame that the “alb” 8v8ers didn’t throw me tell or a rez and explain to me what was happening. Then I could just give you space to go about your business. I am no kinkshamer.

1. An idea: Allow groups that tag themselves as specific “8v8 only” to send tells to other realms as then even the Mids could have told me to keep their fight sacred... &bonus: they’d also be better at organising to meet fellow 8v8ers.

2. Or make 8v8ers names a different colour (other than red) and make it so other RvRers can’t target them (like NPCs)... with this make it so that RvRers cant be targetted by 8v8ers.

3. Or or... just easier to make zone mirrors of the best 8v8 zones (without keeps, guards, relics etc) that you can only go in with 8peeps.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:10 PM by JimD
you can play this game in many different ways, you can solo, stealth zerg, keep take zerg, 8v8 etc
why cry when you cross your way of playing with someone else? If you add an 8v8 expect to get killed 1st whilst both grps pull off, most people who 8v8 are primarily playing to have tough fights on an equal playing field. The only people who are rping farming in that scenario are Los Boyos
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:11 PM by JimD
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:08 PM
Nice vid capture... I really did come out of that tunnel at the wrong time! I was excited to be part of a little skirmish with a Norse savage... Sadly I brought my shaft to the wrong sort of shaft-fight... It was a shame that the “alb” 8v8ers didn’t throw me tell or a rez and explain to me what was happening. Then I could just give you space to go about your business. I am no kinkshamer.

1. An idea: Allow groups that tag themselves as specific “8v8 only” to send tells to other realms as then even the Mids could have told me to keep their fight sacred... &bonus: they’d also be better at organising to meet fellow 8v8ers.

2. Or make 8v8ers names a different colour (other than red) and make it so other RvRers can’t target them (like NPCs)... with this make it so that RvRers cant be targetted by 8v8ers.

3. Or or... just easier to make zone mirrors of the best 8v8 zones (without keeps, guards, relics etc) that you can only go in with 8peeps.

well its fairily obvious what was going on but i'd welcome an arena style matchup any time
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:30 PM by Fk_
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:08 PM
Nice vid capture... I really did come out of that tunnel at the wrong time! I was excited to be part of a little skirmish with a Norse savage... Sadly I brought my shaft to the wrong sort of shaft-fight... It was a shame that the “alb” 8v8ers didn’t throw me tell or a rez and explain to me what was happening. Then I could just give you space to go about your business. I am no kinkshamer.

1. An idea: Allow groups that tag themselves as specific “8v8 only” to send tells to other realms as then even the Mids could have told me to keep their fight sacred... &bonus: they’d also be better at organising to meet fellow 8v8ers.

2. Or make 8v8ers names a different colour (other than red) and make it so other RvRers can’t target them (like NPCs)... with this make it so that RvRers cant be targetted by 8v8ers.

3. Or or... just easier to make zone mirrors of the best 8v8 zones (without keeps, guards, relics etc) that you can only go in with 8peeps.

You can already recognise those players by the different color and the (RP) behind their name, which stands for RP farmers. /s
Thu 2 Apr 2020 6:25 PM by MrWolf
Easy peasy solution: simply remove any gvg tag from any group that enter a "task zone".
So if they want they precious clean fights and precious cleanfight erpees, they must do their orgainzed barbecues away from task zone (task zone are notoriously calm and non-trafficated areas mh?)

If common sense (they are lacking at it) of being in a place where adds will naturally not happen is missing, force them to do it.

We all know why they usually fight in task zone or high traffic ones...
Thu 2 Apr 2020 6:50 PM by JimD
most grps would still respect 8v8 without the flag btw
Thu 2 Apr 2020 6:56 PM by MrWolf
JimD wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 6:50 PM
most grps would still respect 8v8 without the flag btw

you clearly didn't get my point
Thu 2 Apr 2020 6:57 PM by JimD
what havent i got
Thu 2 Apr 2020 7:45 PM by bigne88
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 5:08 PM
Nice vid capture... I really did come out of that tunnel at the wrong time! I was excited to be part of a little skirmish with a Norse savage... Sadly I brought my shaft to the wrong sort of shaft-fight... It was a shame that the “alb” 8v8ers didn’t throw me tell or a rez and explain to me what was happening. Then I could just give you space to go about your business. I am no kinkshamer.

1. An idea: Allow groups that tag themselves as specific “8v8 only” to send tells to other realms as then even the Mids could have told me to keep their fight sacred... &bonus: they’d also be better at organising to meet fellow 8v8ers.

2. Or make 8v8ers names a different colour (other than red) and make it so other RvRers can’t target them (like NPCs)... with this make it so that RvRers cant be targetted by 8v8ers.

3. Or or... just easier to make zone mirrors of the best 8v8 zones (without keeps, guards, relics etc) that you can only go in with 8peeps.

The point is: you are doing nothing wrong adding, just dont be surprised if your "realm mates" pulls out and leave you alone.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:03 PM by Blitze
I had no idea I was adding an official 8v8, I was just a visi soloer running around the task zone. I honestly don’t care about the 8v8 mini-game as long as it isn’t in conflict with general RvR... I believe it’s in conflict when a confused realmmate is left to die without saying anything or rezzing them after. I even /region “what is happening?” Also they didn’t even carry on with the fair 8v8 after...

I think some of my ideas are good... but mirror zones with a special rule set for 8v8 duelling seems the best to implement and leaves the rest of the game as an RvR system.
You could even give different awards than realmpoints. let’s call them 8v8points and you can buy mirror abilities (purge, IP etc) with them that only work in the mirror zones.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:26 PM by Freedomcall
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:03 PM
I had no idea I was adding an official 8v8, I was just a visi soloer running around the task zone. I honestly don’t care about the 8v8 mini-game as long as it isn’t in conflict with general RvR... I believe it’s in conflict when a confused realmmate is left to die without saying anything or rezzing them after. I even /region “what is happening?” Also they didn’t even carry on with the fair 8v8 after...

I think some of my ideas are good... but mirror zones with a special rule set for 8v8 duelling seems the best to implement and leaves the rest of the game as an RvR system.
You could even give different awards than realmpoints. let’s call them 8v8points and you can buy mirror abilities (purge, IP etc) with them that only work in the mirror zones.

If you solo, that means you take all the responsibility and consequences by yourself.
Don't rely on help from your realmmate.
Players in DAoC all have different pov.
Some ppl don't add while others don't give a shit about adding.
You can't anticipate what each of the player thinks.

Just play as you like, and don't blame others for not playing as you expected.
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:30 PM by bigne88
Freedomcall wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:26 PM
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:03 PM
I had no idea I was adding an official 8v8, I was just a visi soloer running around the task zone. I honestly don’t care about the 8v8 mini-game as long as it isn’t in conflict with general RvR... I believe it’s in conflict when a confused realmmate is left to die without saying anything or rezzing them after. I even /region “what is happening?” Also they didn’t even carry on with the fair 8v8 after...

I think some of my ideas are good... but mirror zones with a special rule set for 8v8 duelling seems the best to implement and leaves the rest of the game as an RvR system.
You could even give different awards than realmpoints. let’s call them 8v8points and you can buy mirror abilities (purge, IP etc) with them that only work in the mirror zones.

If you solo, that means you take all the responsibility and consequences by yourself.
Don't rely on help from your realmmate.
Players in DAoC all have different pov.
Some ppl don't add while others don't give a shit about adding.
You can't anticipate what each of the player thinks.

Just play as you like, and don't blame others for not playing as you expected.

This.
Do wathever you like. Others will too.
Solo visi is tough, especially without speed and into reapm task areas.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 1:30 AM by Fk_
Blitze wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 8:03 PM
I had no idea I was adding an official 8v8, I was just a visi soloer running around the task zone. I honestly don’t care about the 8v8 mini-game as long as it isn’t in conflict with general RvR... I believe it’s in conflict when a confused realmmate is left to die without saying anything or rezzing them after. I even /region “what is happening?” Also they didn’t even carry on with the fair 8v8 after...

I think some of my ideas are good... but mirror zones with a special rule set for 8v8 duelling seems the best to implement and leaves the rest of the game as an RvR system.
You could even give different awards than realmpoints. let’s call them 8v8points and you can buy mirror abilities (purge, IP etc) with them that only work in the mirror zones.

Very good idea, i can't wait for this mirror server to see birth~
Fri 3 Apr 2020 2:40 AM by gotwqqd
rafjord wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 1:56 PM
why would these groups needs immunity to win fights lol.
be honest with yourself, if you think your losing fights vs good groups because of immunities then your straight up delusional.
the 8v8 groups are a community. they play all 3 realms, and group often with eachother on multiple realms. we care about a fair fight requiring SKILL not numbers.
when notorious baddies like DT for example, add fights, your ruining a test of skill between 16 people that know eachother.
this will never change. its how we play the game. we don't care about realm pride. we don't care about other realm mates. we care about bragging rights over the other 8v8 people that we laugh/troll/group/play with week in week out.
add our fights and we will continue to pull off and allow you to die.
don't like it? then run round the fight and avoid it
This is what we in Chicago call a jagoff
Complete prickish attitude
Fri 3 Apr 2020 2:42 AM by Azuell
As someone who exclusively runs in a duo/trio, a little advice to people: don't add an 8v8. Just don't do it, it's a lose-lose. You die and get zero rps, their fight is ruined. And then I get to read all the whines on here. If you're a role playing/realm pride person, then you do you I guess, but don't expect everyone to play your way.

My suggestion if you see an 8v8, go sit down and watch it for a couple minutes (from a safe distance, otherwise they will assume you are a threat). They are usually pretty entertaining and it lets both the groups know you are respecting their fight.

We don't typically hang around until the end because I still don't trust 8 mans here but there are a few who will leave you alone going forward, at least for the rest of the night while they remember you. This is very valuable as a solo/small man although it is still pretty rare. I have been noticing groups letting us go a little more often lately though.

Also, there is a difference between a group with 8 people and an 8 man. Don't try the above with a random full group.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 6:18 AM by Idra
This server turns crazy anyway!
Yesterday on EV 2fgh and 1 fgm was fighting 1 fgh, as albs we add, to help our realmates.
Mids and hibs were focused on albs, they killed them and then killed us.
After fight they both ,hibs and mids, put fire, sit and regen, not attcaking each other and then go their own way.
Of courses, when they get CCed in fight their break their CC each other...
This X realm behaviour is corrupting the game and,second thing it happens on EV ,killing the new task system.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:10 AM by rafjord
gotwqqd wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 2:40 AM
rafjord wrote:
Thu 2 Apr 2020 1:56 PM
why would these groups needs immunity to win fights lol.
be honest with yourself, if you think your losing fights vs good groups because of immunities then your straight up delusional.
the 8v8 groups are a community. they play all 3 realms, and group often with eachother on multiple realms. we care about a fair fight requiring SKILL not numbers.
when notorious baddies like DT for example, add fights, your ruining a test of skill between 16 people that know eachother.
this will never change. its how we play the game. we don't care about realm pride. we don't care about other realm mates. we care about bragging rights over the other 8v8 people that we laugh/troll/group/play with week in week out.
add our fights and we will continue to pull off and allow you to die.
don't like it? then run round the fight and avoid it
This is what we in Chicago call a jagoff
Complete prickish attitude
its true what I said tho. if u wanna wear your Albion t shirt and roleplay as a warrior of Arthur, good for you dUdE. don't expect others to care about your playstyle though
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:36 AM by Centenario
Centenario wrote: Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

Centenario wrote: I don't know their name or guildname, just people in EV were doing this all EU night yesterday.
Don't want to know their name or guildname either. Never will.
I just know they are doing bannable offense described above. Farming RP from adders and disguising it as 8v8.
They might occasionally kill each other, but most of what they do is what I described.

Centenario wrote: I am just proving, by the absurd, that you 8v8 need an 8v8 arena, or they could get banned for that absurd scenarios of RP farming adders with full immunity.
You cannot prove that you did not communicate with the opposing party and did not organize to do that style of RP farming.
It is clearly visible that one party disengages, and lets the other party attack the adders who are playing RvR style and not 8v8 style, who are at a disadvantage due to immunity(ies).

Either the 8v8 have to avoid adders by going to the edges of the map, or they need to stop disengaging, or they need their own arena.

By continuing this way they are giving a poor view of RvR/server to casuals.
They appear as the opposite of what they are trying to achieve:
Scum instead of Cream

Centenario wrote: I am just giving facts:
- 8v8 is in an open-RvR area
- is giving immunities to another group
- is communicating with another realm
- is disengaging from a fight to let the other group get free kills on the "adders"
- is doing this scenario multiple times within a short amount of time (anytime adders engage)

In my books that is factual RP farming strategy.

I think devs/gms should take a decision on the 8v8 players, who are farming RP on adders instead of doing actual 8-man RvR.
Either give them an arena or make a rule against it.
They shouldn't be allowed to give immunity, wait for adders and then disengage and farm RP on adders.

If no arena is given for their fancy: making castles in the sandpit
oh btw that arena should be called sandpit
If no arena is given then just make a rule that disengaging a fight to let another realm kill another group of player purposefully is considered unsportsmanlike behavior and is subject to 24hr ban.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:50 AM by MrWolf
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:10 AM
don't expect others to care about your playstyle though

hypocrisy (hɪˈpɒkrəsɪ)
n, pl -sies
1. the practice of professing standards, beliefs, etc, contrary to one's real character or actual behaviour, esp the pretence of virtue and piety
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:52 AM by rafjord
I don't NEED people to respect my playstyle. if they add, I kill them, easy
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:53 AM by rafjord
I am also not QQing for bans on people who don't play how I play...
unlike others here.
example
''QQ I added a fight cos im bad. the people who beat me should be forced to play their own server or be banned QQ end''
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:12 AM by Centenario
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:53 AM
I am also not QQing for bans on people who don't play how I play...
unlike others here.
example
''QQ I added a fight cos im bad. the people who beat me should be forced to play their own server or be banned QQ end''

I use the word "adders" so you understand, but only 8v8 consider "adding" for us plebs we don't see it as adding, we see our realmmates in dire situation and we come to the rescue.

I don't add a fight, I fight and my realmmates are commiting treason by colluding with the enemy (disengage, give immunity, break cc).
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:30 AM by rafjord
now, apologies if your world crashes down around you, but your not a saviour, no1 needs your help. if u see people 8v8ing, no1 wants you to join in.
people who 8v8 do NOT consider you realm mates.
this is nothing personal. don't join in. don't add. its not wanted.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:40 AM by Ele
Centenario wrote:
Centenario wrote: Actually they are not doing 8v8.
They purposely go to an area (EV Alb or Hib or Mid) depending on who is against who.
They constantly mezz/root/stun each other and do not do damage.
They wait for a group to add and kill them with full immunity, while the realm-mate disengages.
They farm RP like that.

Example:
8man alb and 8man mid go to EV, they agree that this time they go to Alb EV entrance.
The 8man alb stuns/roots/mezzes/ns the 8man mid except one who cures mezz/ns.
If they do some damage they just let the healers heal each other's group.

Alb group enters EV and adds the fight.
Alb 8-man (1337 grp) disengages.
Mid 8-man (RP-farmer) crushes the adders thanks to full immunity.
Rince and Repeat until they have gained enough RP to switch to EV Mid doors.

I think these people should be banned for crossrealm communication, crossrealm rp farming.
Or give them an area where they can't do this RP farming strategy, where they have to fight each other instead of waiting for adders and RP farming them with full-immunity.

Centenario wrote: I don't know their name or guildname, just people in EV were doing this all EU night yesterday.
Don't want to know their name or guildname either. Never will.
I just know they are doing bannable offense described above. Farming RP from adders and disguising it as 8v8.
They might occasionally kill each other, but most of what they do is what I described.

Centenario wrote: I am just proving, by the absurd, that you 8v8 need an 8v8 arena, or they could get banned for that absurd scenarios of RP farming adders with full immunity.
You cannot prove that you did not communicate with the opposing party and did not organize to do that style of RP farming.
It is clearly visible that one party disengages, and lets the other party attack the adders who are playing RvR style and not 8v8 style, who are at a disadvantage due to immunity(ies).

Either the 8v8 have to avoid adders by going to the edges of the map, or they need to stop disengaging, or they need their own arena.

By continuing this way they are giving a poor view of RvR/server to casuals.
They appear as the opposite of what they are trying to achieve:
Scum instead of Cream

Centenario wrote: I am just giving facts:
- 8v8 is in an open-RvR area
- is giving immunities to another group
- is communicating with another realm
- is disengaging from a fight to let the other group get free kills on the "adders"
- is doing this scenario multiple times within a short amount of time (anytime adders engage)

In my books that is factual RP farming strategy.

I think devs/gms should take a decision on the 8v8 players, who are farming RP on adders instead of doing actual 8-man RvR.
Either give them an arena or make a rule against it.
They shouldn't be allowed to give immunity, wait for adders and then disengage and farm RP on adders.

If no arena is given for their fancy: making castles in the sandpit
oh btw that arena should be called sandpit
If no arena is given then just make a rule that disengaging a fight to let another realm kill another group of player purposefully is considered unsportsmanlike behavior and is subject to 24hr ban.

Do you realise that it is a bad way of discussing things if you just quote your own posts whilst ignoring any given statement? By doing this, you are discouraging the ones who take time to argue with you instead of ridicule what you say.

Apart from that: 8vs8 is one of the things that keep this server alive. As I stated earlier - we are taking taking numbers from last tuesday into consideration again so I don't have to search for another screenshot - 176 people that are out in the frontiers are doing 8vs8 in EU PT. That equals a fourth zerg, simplifying the matter a bit.
So your proposal is to make the playstyle of those fourth zerg a) a bannable offence or b) force your playstyle on them. I couldn't disagree stronger with these two alternatives.
Hint:
If you want to add an 8vs8, ensure you can win. Join Dark Templar or a comparable guild and roll over 8mans with 24 players, or at least add as a group. If you add solo, you will be killed immediately, without the need to disengage.
Edit: Fixed typo, 22*8=176 not 136
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:42 AM by Centenario
Whatever, you don't seem to understand, i give up trying to reason with you @rafjord

@Devs
If no arena is given then just make a rule that disengaging a fight to let another realm kill another group of player purposefully is considered unsportsmanlike behavior and is subject to 24hr ban.
They are giving immunity, breaking CC, and disengaging so that opponent can reset (and they kill "adders" and farm RP that way).
Most of what they do is killing adders (farming RP) and occasionally they have an 8v8 fight, which nobody cares about except them sandpit toddlers.

Give them an arena where they can measure the size of their toes.

@Ele Im just summarizing cause people keep drowning the fish in useless personal attack posts.
Its not a) not b) its going to your own private arena so you don't disrupt regular RvR with your unsportsmanlike behavior
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:45 AM by Ele
Centenario wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:42 AM
Whatever, you don't seem to understand, i give up trying to reason with you @rafjord

@Devs
If no arena is given then just make a rule that disengaging a fight to let another realm kill another group of player purposefully is considered unsportsmanlike behavior and is subject to 24hr ban.
They are giving immunity, breaking CC, and disengaging so that opponent can reset (and they kill "adders" and farm RP that way).
Most of what they do is killing adders (farming RP) and occasionally they have an 8v8 fight, which nobody cares about except them sandpit toddlers.

Give them an arena where they can measure the size of their toes.

@Ele Im just summarizing cause people keep drowning the fish in useless personal attack posts.
A summary is appreciated. An elaborate reaction would be a nice addition.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:46 AM by rafjord
I love your RP farming argument.

If you didn't add the fight, we wouldn't have to farm you.

sigh.

if you INSIST on adding a fight, don't be mad when u get wrecked.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:51 AM by Razur Ur
Centenario wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 7:36 AM
I think devs/gms should take a decision on the 8v8 players, who are farming RP on adders instead of doing actual 8-man RvR.
Either give them an arena or make a rule against it.
They shouldn't be allowed to give immunity, wait for adders and then disengage and farm RP on adders.

If no arena is given for their fancy: making castles in the sandpit
oh btw that arena should be called sandpit
If no arena is given then just make a rule that disengaging a fight to let another realm kill another group of player purposefully is considered unsportsmanlike behavior and is subject to 24hr ban.

Damn bro take less drugs or something because you already have enough 8vs8 paranoia ;-D
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:57 AM by Loki
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:30 AM
this is nothing personal. don't join in. don't add. its not wanted.
the same goes for you when you pass by a 1v1
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:09 AM by MrWolf
Ele wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:40 AM
8vs8 is one of the things that keep this server alive. As I stated earlier - we are taking taking numbers from last tuesday into consideration again so I don't have to search for another screenshot - 136 people that are out in the frontiers are doing 8vs8 in EU PT.

at the same time total server population was around 1900ish.

so you 136 engaged in your private penis lenghts comparisons were merely just a under 10% of the pop.

you are not taking alive anything, even if you think so in your megalomanic minds. sorry.



same as always answer: do you want to play your minigame inside the game? go do it in a completely unpopulated area or just ask for an arena only for 8v8.
You'll be happy, all the others that don't give a fuck about 8v8 will be happy too.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:10 AM by rafjord
Loki wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:57 AM
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:30 AM
this is nothing personal. don't join in. don't add. its not wanted.
the same goes for you when you pass by a 1v1

prolific 1v1 adder am I ?
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:11 AM by rafjord
MrWolf wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:09 AM
Ele wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:40 AM
8vs8 is one of the things that keep this server alive. As I stated earlier - we are taking taking numbers from last tuesday into consideration again so I don't have to search for another screenshot - 136 people that are out in the frontiers are doing 8vs8 in EU PT.

at the same time total server population was around 1900ish.

so you 136 engaged in your private penis lenghts comparisons were merely just a under 10% of the pop.

you are not taking alive anything, even if you think so in your megalomanic minds. sorry.

don't be mad that ur bad :\
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:18 AM by Centenario
Rafjord please stop the flooding. Do you suffer from a complex of inferiority? [rhetorical question, please don't answer]

1) Give a 8v8 arena to the 1-150 people that want to partake into 8v8.
2) Prevent them from deteriorating the community with unsportsmanlike behavior in the regular RvR zones with a new rule.
3) If they continue to do RP-farming disguised into 8v8 then ban these players.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:18 AM by Razur Ur
I run out of popcorn, it's like in the good old days here :-D
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:19 AM by MrWolf
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:11 AM
don't be mad that ur bad :\

that is the point. i'm really not mad about i'm bad, i don't even mind. it's just a game.

i don't need (as like you) gratification of being GOOD or PROH at a game to be happy with myself.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:22 AM by rafjord
MrWolf wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:19 AM
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:11 AM
don't be mad that ur bad :\

that is the point. i'm really not mad about i'm bad, i don't even mind. it's just a game.

i don't need (as like you) gratification of being GOOD or PROH at a game to be happy with myself.

not mad, but crying for banhammer cos people are better than you. ok mate.

Centenario, maybe we shud make a separate server for ****players, then you could belong to the mediocre masses and fight as many doors as you like. leave this server for the people who can actually play
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:24 AM by MrWolf
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:22 AM
not mad, but crying for banhammer cos people are better than you. ok mate.



please let me see where i cried for banhammer.

because now you're also pretending me saying things i never wrote.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:26 AM by Ele
MrWolf wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:09 AM
Ele wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:40 AM
8vs8 is one of the things that keep this server alive. As I stated earlier - we are taking taking numbers from last tuesday into consideration again so I don't have to search for another screenshot - 136 people that are out in the frontiers are doing 8vs8 in EU PT.

at the same time total server population was around 1900ish.

so you 136 engaged in your private penis lenghts comparisons were merely just a under 10% of the pop.

you are not taking alive anything, even if you think so in your megalomanic minds. sorry.
...

I might be wrong and have no data/screenshot at hand, but /u gave out roughly 750 people in NF on Tuesday evening, so we are talking about more like 20%. Client numbers don't really help, same goes for unnecessary insults.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:28 AM by rafjord
what exactly was YOUR suggestion then?
where you with the 'ban a certain playstyle' crowd or not ?
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:30 AM by MrWolf
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:28 AM
what exactly was YOUR suggestion then?
where you with the 'ban a certain playstyle' crowd or not ?

i quote myself for your convenience even if i really shouldn't have to.


MrWolf wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:09 AM
same as always answer: do you want to play your minigame inside the game? go do it in a completely unpopulated area or just ask for an arena only for 8v8.
You'll be happy, all the others that don't give a fuck about 8v8 will be happy too.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:35 AM by Centenario
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:28 AM
what exactly was YOUR suggestion then?
where you with the 'ban a certain playstyle' crowd or not ?

Centenario wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:18 AM
Rafjord please stop the flooding. Do you suffer from a complex of inferiority? [rhetorical question, please don't answer]

1) Give a 8v8 arena to the 1-150 people that want to partake into 8v8.
2) Prevent them from deteriorating the community with unsportsmanlike behavior in the regular RvR zones with a new rule.
3) If they continue to do RP-farming disguised into 8v8 then ban these players.

Suggestion has been clearly to have a 8v8 arena the whole time...
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:37 AM by Blitze
Honestly the more I read the opinion of the 8v8ers and the other server inhabitants doing the other forms of RvR... it all seems to point too a perfect solution.
A separate arena or mirror zones where 8v8ers don’t have to deal with people ruining their fair fights.
Additionally, other server inhabitants wouldn’t have to dance around this separate contest.
Finally, there would be no flames, QQs, whines etc and wasted forum posts on this clash of ideals.

The 8v8ers could get a separate forum subsection, some rewards other than “realm”points...They could even disable the friendly fire and kill your realms.. hell they could go further and have a democratic vote on removal realms entirely... I might even dip in and have a look as I’ve always wanted to play a lurikeen friar.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:38 AM by rafjord
Sooo, you want people of a certain playstyle to be separated from others...
pretty dubious ideology mate....

people can play where they want, and how they want.
If we want to 8v8 at a dock, we will. If you add, which you are fully entitled to, we will pull off and kill you. your kind of at a lose lose situation

your gonna have to get used to it im afraid /shrug
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:41 AM by Blitze
But there is no reason too,,, everyone gets what they want with a mirror zone.
(Unless some 8v8ers actually enjoy the pulling off of fights to kill adders. But these types of 8mams could stay in regular zones and farm small fish to their hearts content.)
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:43 AM by Centenario
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:38 AM
people can play where they want, and how they want.
If we want to 8v8 at a dock, we will. If you add, which you are fully entitled to, we will pull off and kill you.

Im okay with that as long as you stop breaking CC so people have a chance to win the fight, but the current 8v8 RP farmers are just breaking CC of opposing party and giving immunity so that they reset their fight faster, at the same time they RP farm "adders".

That has to become bannable behavior.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:47 AM by rafjord
why should it be bannable?

You already gain advantage for adding an ongoing fight.

2 teams, that may have burnt RA's, then have to fight a 3rd team that has the advantage of surprise, positioning, RA's.....

admins are never going to enforce the banning of what u propose. this should give you some indication that its unrealistic what you ask for.

also unrealistic is forcing people to play elsewhere, because you don't like what they do :\

you have absolutely ZERO chance of admins creating a mirror zone btw. id save your breath.

If your favourite playstyle is adding fights then beg admins for more pvp events. Even amongst the 8v8 community, these generally become an add fest.
But still, when you lose, don't blame everyone else. If you want respect from the 8v8 community, win your own fights, respect others fights, and stop trying to get rp's by adding on others hard work.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 10:48 AM by Blitze
I am not proposing forcing people to play elsewhere... People can play how they want (to some extent: as long as they aren’t hurting each other’s play style enough that it just forces people to quit the server) Server health is important.
I am proposing an entire 8v8 zone or plenty of zones, or a rotation. Whatever. It would be completely optional to fight there, and if you did do then you would not be in danger of hurting other people’s playstyle whilst also others wouldn’t be in danger of hurting yours. It’s such an easy fix.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 10:51 AM by Uthred
The basic rule for RvR is:

You are allowed to add. You are allowed to not add. You can choose whom you want to fight. You can choose whom you dont want to fight.

Thats the foundation and from where to start. It gets more tricky if it comes to (intentional) CC breaking. There is no clear blueprint to this. Each and every case is different and has to be reviewed individually. We had multiple cases where players where warned and/or banned for intentional CC breaking. It was done by 8mans as well by solos & smallmans.
It is a huge difference who is breaking CC for whom against who. In general: Helping another realm against your own realm mates is not allowed, however, helping another realm against the third realm is fine. But dont take this as a freepass. Like said above it always depends on the situation.
Another really important thing to determine if something is punishable or not, is if there have been any arrangements before. This is also something which is really different from case to case. One thing of the 8mans is that if 2 groups are fighting, and a 3rd group is adding, that both groups switch onto the adding group. This is something that we tolerate and that is also something which is covered by the above stated basic rule. This is btw also valid for any other groupsize and not an 8mans only rule.
Some people would call this respect for your enemy, some people dont care about it. There is no right or wrong on how to play this game. I think that is also one of the reasons why Daoc RvR is something special: In 90% of the cases you dont know what will happen next. This is the major difference to an arena-based pvp-game, where you know how many and which enemies are waiting for you.
But in the end, everyone playing this server is part of this community. You dont have to like each other, you dont even have to respect each other. But try at least to not insult each other. That would make the Staffs life way more comfortable. Thank you for reading.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 11:27 AM by Blitze
Yea... it’s such a gray area... I don’t envy the staff trying to find the line where behaviour of a certain playstyle becomes too toxic to others.

Good luck I guess.

On the upside, at least with 8v8 (aside from say gray-gankers) a mirror/arena would be an off-the-shelf fix.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 11:50 AM by MrWolf
Blitze wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 11:27 AM
Yea... it’s such a gray area... I don’t envy the staff trying to find the line where behaviour of a certain playstyle becomes too toxic to others.

Good luck I guess.

On the upside, at least with 8v8 (aside from say gray-gankers) a mirror/arena would be an off-the-shelf fix.

What you don't get is that they really don't want just clean fights.

They are a sub community. They have their discord, they shared accounts before the rule was enforced to always have the most ranked setup, they basically know each other and play together from long times.

That's the thing, they know that this behavior is (Uthred words) tolerated, so they use it at their advantage.

They roam the task zones to do 8v8 cause, u know, so they get also the task erpees and bonus multipliers, strong of their agreement between gvg groups to join the fight against anything that adds.

Two gank 8men are a threat to anything up to a zerg of uncoordinated and social/pugged people, so they bath in these conditions and enjoy them with their bullying "we play where we want add at your risk".

That's it.

Is basically "join us or miss the luxury of tagteaming adders".

But staff wrote down, so I think everyone will simply have to live with it.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 11:53 AM by rafjord
u mad that we have friends mr wolf ?

or mad because u not only cannot beat us through skill, you cant even beat us with numbers now.

feelsbad to be you

you and your zerg friends are lucky we don't actualy team up with 16 people to ruin your zerg fun. because if we wanted to, we could. but we don't. we let you do your thing. the only time our paths cross is when you add our fights and die.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 12:15 PM by Valaraukar
rafjord wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 11:53 AM
u mad that we have friends mr wolf ?

or mad because u not only cannot beat us through skill, you cant even beat us with numbers now.

feelsbad to be you

you and your zerg friends are lucky we don't actualy team up with 16 people to ruin your zerg fun. because if we wanted to, we could. but we don't. we let you do your thing. the only time our paths cross is when you add our fights and die.

Omg, I'm shaking with fear! I feel so lucky now, thank you! 😂

Uthred... What's about "if there have been any arrangements before." theirs are ALWAYS arranged fights, they share the same discord, they shared also the same accounts.... What else is left to be arranged? They break cc against their own realm mates, they insult them if there is an add, and have no shame to inc a solo player or a smallman if they are so unlucky to cross their path, but then thy whine when they are wiped by 3 fgs. And no, they are not part of our community, they have their own community that gives absolutely nothing to this game and to the server, are arrogant and harassing with other players because they feel they are the "Pros".
Returning to the funny rafjord (who, as his other friends don't even care to put his toons name so he cannot be recognized in game).... You should feel lucky that your distasteful behaviour is so tolerated here. I hope it will have an end, sooner or later.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 1:20 PM by Chaskha
The moment you put your ego in a game, it's time to evaluate your success in real life ...

All my respect to the 8v8 people who play the game to the perfection without having to gloat or try to put down others, you are incredible players.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 3:21 PM by Uthred
Valaraukar wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 12:15 PM
Uthred... What's about "if there have been any arrangements before." theirs are ALWAYS arranged fights, they share the same discord, they shared also the same accounts.... What else is left to be arranged? They break cc against their own realm mates, they insult them if there is an add, and have no shame to inc a solo player or a smallman if they are so unlucky to cross their path, but then thy whine when they are wiped by 3 fgs. And no, they are not part of our community, they have their own community that gives absolutely nothing to this game and to the server, are arrogant and harassing with other players because they feel they are the "Pros".
Returning to the funny rafjord (who, as his other friends don't even care to put his toons name so he cannot be recognized in game).... You should feel lucky that your distasteful behaviour is so tolerated here. I hope it will have an end, sooner or later.

If someone is breaking CC intentionally, just appeal it.
If someone is insulting you, just appeal it.
If someone is "whining" about adds or ganking smaller numbers, just ignore it.
If someone is insulting you, just appeal it (and the posts get deleted and the player warned, like i just did.)

My above wall of text had two intentions: To clarify our RvR rules, which appeal to everyone and to stop the ongoing insults. Any further insults will result in further punishments. If you are not able to communicate in a proper way, better dont post here.
Fri 3 Apr 2020 10:41 PM by Ferboten
Valaraukar wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 12:15 PM
Returning to the funny rafjord (who, as his other friends don't even care to put his toons name so he cannot be recognized in game)....

Yes, rafjord is a coward by not listing his toon's name, how could anyone know that he is Rafjord in game?
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM by Eoril
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)
Sun 5 Apr 2020 3:52 PM by JimD
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

not rly mate
Sun 5 Apr 2020 4:03 PM by Quik
JimD wrote:
Sun 5 Apr 2020 3:52 PM
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

not rly mate

I won't say all are this way, but I will say a lot are.

What I love is how 8v8 groups love to act like they are honorable, but as was posted, most 8v8 roll over soloers the second they see them as well has xping groups and I know this because I've been leveling some albs lately and I have seen first hand these "skilled" groups rolling xp'ers and soloers. It used to be while leveling groups would ignore me most of the time, but the last couple months I have seen ONE kobold stealthier who ran past me and ignored me...ONE.

As I posted in another thread I understand and accept "red is dead" and I don't expect other realms to ignore me even while I am grey, but lets not act like 8v8 groups have some special honor that they follow and that they leave lvlers and soloers alone because most don't.

The few 8v8 honorable groups are getting a bad rap, but those same groups aren't coming on the forums. The 8v8 people here on the forums are the ones screaming for special treatment while not wanting to give that same special treatment.
Sun 5 Apr 2020 4:35 PM by inoeth
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk
Sun 5 Apr 2020 9:23 PM by Eoril
inoeth wrote:
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk

Do you realize that I can say exactly the same thing to you?

What do you know about my game experience ?
Do you really deny that some fight are organized?
Do you really deny that there is a discord ?
Please don't be so childish.
Sun 5 Apr 2020 10:13 PM by Ele
MrWolf wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 9:09 AM
Ele wrote:
Fri 3 Apr 2020 8:40 AM
8vs8 is one of the things that keep this server alive. As I stated earlier - we are taking taking numbers from last tuesday into consideration again so I don't have to search for another screenshot - 176 people that are out in the frontiers are doing 8vs8 in EU PT.

at the same time total server population was around 1900ish.

so you 136 engaged in your private penis lenghts comparisons were merely just a under 10% of the pop.

you are not taking alive anything, even if you think so in your megalomanic minds. sorry.
same as always answer: do you want to play your minigame inside the game? go do it in a completely unpopulated area or just ask for an arena only for 8v8.
You'll be happy, all the others that don't give a fuck about 8v8 will be happy too.

I had a typo in my previous post, 22 listed groups equals 176, not 136 players. Apart from the typo it is safe to say that this is the size of a fourth big zerg. There is nothing megalomanic etc. going on, it's just data.
In addition to that, I checked /u a few times over the last two evenings (EU PT), and it showed roughly 1000 people in NF. So with 176 players who are on /gvg list, close to 20% of the people that are rvring are interested in the 8man game.

Eoril wrote: 8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

[...]

Do you really deny that some fight are organized?
Do you really deny that there is a discord ?


I'm not going to deny that there is an 8vs8 discord, but apart from lfg, blaming, bragging, trolling and the occasional discussion if another zone than the realm that gets invaded could be chosen as the go-to spot for 8mans, there is not much going on. With /gvg list there is not much need for organizing fights, as groups can see each others zone in there, and in this zones the spots for fights are limited by terrain and spots. Might still happen, but I'd suppose it is not really used a lot.
Sun 5 Apr 2020 11:22 PM by JimD
Eoril wrote:
Sun 5 Apr 2020 9:23 PM
inoeth wrote:
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk

Do you realize that I can say exactly the same thing to you?

What do you know about my game experience ?
Do you really deny that some fight are organized?
Do you really deny that there is a discord ?
Please don't be so childish.
ye there is a discord but we dont organise fights no, the gvg list says where all grps are its not really hard to figure that part out
Mon 6 Apr 2020 7:28 AM by inoeth
Eoril wrote:
Sun 5 Apr 2020 9:23 PM
inoeth wrote:
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk

Do you realize that I can say exactly the same thing to you?

What do you know about my game experience ?
Do you really deny that some fight are organized?
Do you really deny that there is a discord ?
Please don't be so childish.

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk
dont be so childish
Mon 6 Apr 2020 8:41 AM by Eoril
the way you use attack ad hominem says a lot about the reality of what i describe
Mon 6 Apr 2020 9:44 AM by Vincent123
lmaoing@your life guys, "is just a game, why you have to be mad"
Wed 8 Apr 2020 3:56 PM by joshisanonymous
If I put together a set 8man, I would do it with the intention of not only seeing if we can win 8v8 fights but seeing we can pull off 8vX fights, because this is an RvR game, not an arena game. It's the same way I approach soloing: I plan not only for how to win 1v1 but also how to win 1vX, because it's an open frontier. That's a feature of the game, not a bug: RvR is meant to be unpredictable and part of the fun is supposed to be seeing if you can adapt and handle that unpredictableness.

Back in the day, it seemed like 8man groups did plan for 8vX fights. I remember hardcore 8mans vs casual zergs being a regular thing on multiple servers. Somewhere along the line, though, that mentality changed and now it's all about "fair fights". (BTW, /gvg wasn't implemented so you could have these "fair fights", it was implemented so you have a better chance of encountering similar sized groups.)
Wed 8 Apr 2020 4:09 PM by Amser
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 3:56 PM
(BTW, /gvg wasn't implemented so you could have these "fair fights", it was implemented so you have a better chance of encountering similar sized groups.)

The way I take /gvg would be the opposite then of the way you are perceiving it.

/gvg is only for 8 mans.

If they wanted "similar size groups" fighting, there would only be one command for all lists. As it stands, there is /fairfight for <7 or /gvg for 8.

If they didn't expect 8v8 "fair fights" in the /gvg, they also wouldn't have the /gvg fairfight command if both teams feel like there wasn't adds...

Basically what you say here is opposite of what is implemented in the game.
Wed 8 Apr 2020 6:08 PM by joshisanonymous
Amser wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 4:09 PM
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 3:56 PM
(BTW, /gvg wasn't implemented so you could have these "fair fights", it was implemented so you have a better chance of encountering similar sized groups.)

The way I take /gvg would be the opposite then of the way you are perceiving it.

/gvg is only for 8 mans.

If they wanted "similar size groups" fighting, there would only be one command for all lists. As it stands, there is /fairfight for <7 or /gvg for 8.

If they didn't expect 8v8 "fair fights" in the /gvg, they also wouldn't have the /gvg fairfight command if both teams feel like there wasn't adds...

Basically what you say here is opposite of what is implemented in the game.

Replace "similar" with "same". /gvg has absolutely nothing to do with avoiding adds; it just means that you won't spend an hour in a zone that has no other 8mans in it.

I mean, it tells you if you're in a zone with multiple 8mans, right? So if we're gonna go with the logic of what it shows you is the exact fight you should get, then /gvg is really about promoting adds between groups of 8...
Wed 8 Apr 2020 6:27 PM by Amser
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 6:08 PM
Amser wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 4:09 PM
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 3:56 PM
(BTW, /gvg wasn't implemented so you could have these "fair fights", it was implemented so you have a better chance of encountering similar sized groups.)

The way I take /gvg would be the opposite then of the way you are perceiving it.

/gvg is only for 8 mans.

If they wanted "similar size groups" fighting, there would only be one command for all lists. As it stands, there is /fairfight for <7 or /gvg for 8.

If they didn't expect 8v8 "fair fights" in the /gvg, they also wouldn't have the /gvg fairfight command if both teams feel like there wasn't adds...

Basically what you say here is opposite of what is implemented in the game.

Replace "similar" with "same". /gvg has absolutely nothing to do with avoiding adds; it just means that you won't spend an hour in a zone that has no other 8mans in it.

I mean, it tells you if you're in a zone with multiple 8mans, right? So if we're gonna go with the logic of what it shows you is the exact fight you should get, then /gvg is really about promoting adds between groups of 8...

The list is only visible to people in /gvg. So it doesn’t promote adds outside of /gvg. The GM’s have come out and stated what they feel is acceptable as a /gvg fairfight. A single or so add here or there that does change the outcome of the battle is acceptable. A third group AJing two 8 mans fighting would not be considered a /gvg fairfight.
So yes, they are promoting with reward by implementation 8v8 as a “fair fight”. So by design, they are recommending avoiding adds... or you won’t have both sides accepting /gvg fairfight.
“/gvg” doesn’t promote it, if that is what you are trying to say.
“/gvg fairfight” does though and is a command within /gvg.
Wed 8 Apr 2020 7:17 PM by joshisanonymous
Amser wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 6:27 PM
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 6:08 PM
Amser wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 4:09 PM
The way I take /gvg would be the opposite then of the way you are perceiving it.

/gvg is only for 8 mans.

If they wanted "similar size groups" fighting, there would only be one command for all lists. As it stands, there is /fairfight for <7 or /gvg for 8.

If they didn't expect 8v8 "fair fights" in the /gvg, they also wouldn't have the /gvg fairfight command if both teams feel like there wasn't adds...

Basically what you say here is opposite of what is implemented in the game.

Replace "similar" with "same". /gvg has absolutely nothing to do with avoiding adds; it just means that you won't spend an hour in a zone that has no other 8mans in it.

I mean, it tells you if you're in a zone with multiple 8mans, right? So if we're gonna go with the logic of what it shows you is the exact fight you should get, then /gvg is really about promoting adds between groups of 8...

The list is only visible to people in /gvg. So it doesn’t promote adds outside of /gvg. The GM’s have come out and stated what they feel is acceptable as a /gvg fairfight. A single or so add here or there that does change the outcome of the battle is acceptable. A third group AJing two 8 mans fighting would not be considered a /gvg fairfight.
So yes, they are promoting with reward by implementation 8v8 as a “fair fight”. So by design, they are recommending avoiding adds... or you won’t have both sides accepting /gvg fairfight.
“/gvg” doesn’t promote it, if that is what you are trying to say.
“/gvg fairfight” does though and is a command within /gvg.

I didn't realize there was the extra /gvg cleanfight component that /fairfight doesn't have. I don't think this actually changes much, though. Sure, if it turned out to be perfectly balanced 8v8 fight after the fact, then you get some extra RPs, but their discussion of this is centered around making people feel more inclined to roam in groups of 8, not specifically in arranging those perfectly balanced encounters. Like I said, it's all about increasing the likelihood of getting encounters like that, not about forcing arena-style gameplay into an RvR game. If it was really meant that way, why is /gvg cleanfight used after fights instead of before, and why can groups see every other group in /gvg instead of just one? It would make more sense to have just the /gvg cleanfight command, to be used before engaging anyone, and have it tell you the location of a single other 8man instead of all of the 8mans if the intention was to ensure balanced fights with no adds.
Mon 13 Apr 2020 4:30 PM by Eoril
inoeth wrote:
Sun 5 Apr 2020 4:35 PM
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk

btw it's true you are a pro on this subject : you add all my fights.

Every time i meet your grp in rvr, you prove me right
Mon 13 Apr 2020 5:06 PM by inoeth
Eoril wrote:
Mon 13 Apr 2020 4:30 PM
inoeth wrote:
Sun 5 Apr 2020 4:35 PM
Eoril wrote:
Sat 4 Apr 2020 7:32 PM
8v8 are mostly "arranged fights" and those guys are not shy to add others 8v8 if the players are not their little friends of their parralel discord.

(not all grp)

lol if you dont have a clue maybe dont talk

btw it's true you are a pro on this subject : you add all my fights.

Every time i meet your grp in rvr, you prove me right

lol what grp are you talking about? i solo all the time
Thu 16 Apr 2020 6:57 AM by Noashakra
What's ridiculous, it's to do those 8vs8 next to where the action is.
Not all the people are doing 8vs8 no add, and doing it next to the hotspots mean that you have to think twice before going in when two groups fight.

So please go make your 8vs8 on the realm without action. I know, you would give up those sweet free rps you are looking for, but at least, your argument of "we want clean 8vs8" would make sense.
Thu 16 Apr 2020 9:00 AM by Blitze
Yea, it’s easy to observe whilst playing the server that the 8v8ers are happy to collect free RPs by chasing Smallmans & solos 4000 units across the map.

Yet the community tells us repeatedly that they just want clean fair fights.

So in my opinion, we and the Devs should take them at their word and make a separate set of mirror zones for them to 8v8.... it can have different rules and even rewards.

The normal zones will then have a more normal RvR rule set where some of the more questionable 8v8 behaviour can be limited by rules.
Thu 16 Apr 2020 11:50 AM by Noashakra
And when those solo/small man adds them after they get rolled over time and time again, they /yell to stop their fight and roll on them. The double standards are real.
Tue 28 Apr 2020 8:37 PM by Eoril
Classic.
We arrive on a group in rest.
We respect : we don't attack.
30 sec after, inc from back.
Guess who...
Tue 28 Apr 2020 10:39 PM by Patron
In every group of humans are good and bad folks.
U meet the bad ones. I hope u mind their names and guildcolours
Fri 1 May 2020 12:52 AM by Rodimus
joshisanonymous wrote:
Wed 8 Apr 2020 3:56 PM
If I put together a set 8man, I would do it with the intention of not only seeing if we can win 8v8 fights but seeing we can pull off 8vX fights, because this is an RvR game, not an arena game. It's the same way I approach soloing: I plan not only for how to win 1v1 but also how to win 1vX, because it's an open frontier. That's a feature of the game, not a bug: RvR is meant to be unpredictable and part of the fun is supposed to be seeing if you can adapt and handle that unpredictableness.

Back in the day, it seemed like 8man groups did plan for 8vX fights. I remember hardcore 8mans vs casual zergs being a regular thing on multiple servers. Somewhere along the line, though, that mentality changed and now it's all about "fair fights". (BTW, /gvg wasn't implemented so you could have these "fair fights", it was implemented so you have a better chance of encountering similar sized groups.)

This. On previous servers what set the good 8 man groups apart from the rest was being able to handle any situation and still win, 8vX. However, on Phoenix all of these so called 8 man guilds pull off and reset a fight if a random mob looks at them the wrong way. It is a bunch of carebears that only care about rps and their subject views on what is fair RvR.

Sadly, The server has encouraged and continues to enable this behavior with the /gvg command.
Fri 1 May 2020 4:53 AM by stewbeedoo
Blitze wrote:
Thu 16 Apr 2020 9:00 AM
Yea, it’s easy to observe whilst playing the server that the 8v8ers are happy to collect free RPs by chasing Smallmans & solos 4000 units across the map.

Yet the community tells us repeatedly that they just want clean fair fights.

So in my opinion, we and the Devs should take them at their word and make a separate set of mirror zones for them to 8v8.... it can have different rules and even rewards.

The normal zones will then have a more normal RvR rule set where some of the more questionable 8v8 behaviour can be limited by rules.

Weren't you the Skald with the Shammy that added on my fight today then chased me a quite a ways on my Ranger?
Fri 1 May 2020 9:23 AM by WildWilbur
Pao wrote:
Mon 13 Jan 2020 11:17 PM
Hate to hear dumb stuff like this especially when I get killed solo all the time nobody honour my soloness....

They honour it with /rofl on your body after hunting you down with SL...
Fri 1 May 2020 9:27 AM by Blitze
Nah my only lvl50 is a friar and I solo.

Besides I am not too bothered about people adding my 1v1s, it’s a RvR game and red is dead. I am more worried about the effect disengaging (to let other realms farm your realmmates) has on the community.

Recently I have avoided EV completely (regardless of whether it’s the task zone) and stuck to fighting at bridges and docks as you can get back after death super quick. Also it seems the only 8v8 groups that go there are just looking for farming cheap RPs (aka mackerel fishing for solos n duos) and often guards and the build up of respawning solos can kill them.
This topic is locked and you can't reply.

Return to Ask the Team or the latest topics